Mitigating Inland Marine Losses

Author, Casey Craig, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Inland marine insurance can sometimes be a forgotten line item in some construction companies’ insurance portfolio. This insurance covers your materials, equipment and tools once they are in the field or in transit. Sometimes insured’s feel they have coverage through their property insurance but once the equipment, materials or tools leave your premises, inland marine is the line of insurance that covers you.

Historically, inland marine coverage had fewer losses than other lines of coverage and this type of insurance had not seen a change in premium. However, this has changed in recent years with bolder criminals stealing larger equipment and materials from jobsites, breaking into work trucks to take higher valued tools and vandalism. What are some ways you can cut down on cost and help insulate yourself from losses?

By utilizing new technology to track where you are storing your materials and equipment overnight and investing in security measures, you can help prevent claims and reduce premiums. With theft on the rise, it is a good time to make sure you are storing your materials and equipment in the best way possible. Placing air tags or similar GPS tools on larger equipment is extremely helpful in recovering stolen items and tracking where they are being stored. If leaving equipment at jobsites, removing batteries is also helpful but if possible, try to not leave equipment at the jobsite. Train your employees to properly secure and store equipment if they are taking it home in their work truck. Most theft or vandalism are crimes that are a result of convenience or opportunistic. The harder it is to commit crime because of preventative measures, the less likely the crime will happen.

Ensure you have proper limits for your equipment and materials with your carrier. In reviewing and insuring your tools and equipment, it is important to understanding what is considered miscellaneous tools. Typically, this might be tools with a value less than $2,500, thus necessitating the need to “schedule” equipment above that value. Often times, we see insureds who have aggregate miscellaneous tools limits much higher than needed and then also including those tools or equipment on the scheduled equipment list.

When insuring the materials that will be used on a job, it is important to distinguish between a transit, jobsite and temporary location limits. These limits should be specific to your actual needs and not necessarily always the same values, that is another common mistake we see in auditing insurance portfolios. These vital discussions can help you save on premiums and ensure you are properly insulated from exposures.

While inland marine insurance isn’t typically one of your largest expenses in your insurance portfolio, it is something you need to monitor so costs do not creep up over time from frequency of losses. With rising costs in both auto and property insurance, it is becoming more important to make sure you are insulating your company from risk as much as possible to keep your controllable exposures down.

Discussing your inland marine coverage with your insurance broker regularly can help keep premiums and losses down. If you have questions relating to inland marine or any other of your insurance coverage, please reach out to me at ccraig@ranchomesa.com or (619)438-6900.

Employer’s Guide to Handling Cumulative Trauma Claims

Author, Casey Craig, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

A growing thorn in employers’ sides has been the rise of worker’s compensation cumulative trauma (CT) claims. Cumulative trauma refers to the ongoing psychological and physical injuries that accumulate over time, often resulting from repetitive stress or exposure to adverse conditions. Employees missing time can lead to larger workers’ compensation claims, lower moral, and less efficiency. It can be easy as an employer to take a defensive stance and fight each one of these, but there are a few factors that must be taken into consideration prior to deciding if you should settle or challenge these claims.

Not every CT claim should to be fought. As hard as it is to hear, you can win the battle but lose the war. Sometimes the cost of gathering information, medical reviews, time spent away from operations and litigation can add up to more than it would have cost to settle these claims. This is extremely tough to achieve in construction as the burden is on the employer to prove that there is no way that their stated injuries could have happened while working for you.

Employers can proactively fight CT claims by staying ahead of the exposure as much as possible. This means making sure your workers have the safest, most ergonomic-friendly environment possible. Stress and repetitive motion are two of the largest causes of CT claims. Trying to keep your employees from doing the same repetitive task over and over is extremely important in keeping both moral high and frequency of claims lower. However, this can be difficult for most construction companies with the need to perform the same motion over and over, but it is necessary to have your employees switch up tasks if at all possible.

This does not mean that every cumulative trauma claim should be settled either. We are seeing younger and younger employees filing these once they have been let go or have chosen to leave. These post termination claims typically come attached with an applicant attorney and can include multiple body parts being named that appear initially as fraudulent statements. If it is determined that there truly was no record of injury and they are able to perform all normal duties, fighting the claim may make sense.

Each claim is unique and needs to be handled as such. Relying on your insurance broker and carrier claim consultant for guidance is critical in staying focused on the facts, not the frustration and emotions that often accompany these types of claims. While settling a claim that could be fraudulent can be frustrating and does have an impact on your experience modification rate, it can often be the best path towards minimizing costs and maintaining lower loss ratios that lead directly to lower renewal premiums, which is the ultimate goal.

If you have any questions about how to handle cumulative trauma claims, reach out to me at ccraig@ranchomesa.com or (619)438-6900.

Return to Work Programs: Best Practices for Handling Workers’ Comp Claims

Author, Casey Craig, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

How do you handle the situation when a great employee is injured but not quite ready to return to full duty? We do all that we can to prevent injuries and make sure once they do happen our employees are taken care of quickly and properly. The one true variable we have in our control, after a claim has been filed, is how to accommodate employees that are injured but not able to return to normal duties until deemed fully recovered.

Your experience modification rate (X-MOD) is a very important component in your premiums and potentially securing bids in states like California. Every company has a primary threshold that is unique to the company. This is a dollar amount per claim that, once the medical, permanent disability, and temporary disability surpasses this threshold, has no further impact to your X-MOD. Carriers have medical review teams set in place to ensure that the medical portion of each claim is as low as possible, permanent disability is dictated by the treating doctor, so the only portion of each claim we have control over is how the temporary disability will be handled. Sometimes, even that is out of our control if an injured employee is not able to work in any capacity.

Ideally, your workers’ compensation doctor will quickly give you work restrictions and you will be able to determine if you have any available work within those restrictions. The bigger question is what to do with these employees if they are not fit for regular duty? Is it best to let the carrier handle the temporary disability portion of the claim, have the employee come back and work in your office doing odd jobs, or utilize companies like ReEmployAbility or carrier programs where they can work at any number of nonprofit organizations? Temporary disability mismanagement can add up very quickly and lead to a small claim turning into a claim that heavily impacts your X-MOD.

Making sure your employee feels valued and that they have a job to come back to is a great way to keep claims cost down and employee morale high. When employees sit at home waiting to recover, they may feel helpless and uncertain about their future, are exposed to countless commercials about injured workers and lawyers that claim they can make them rich. Keeping them at work, in some capacity, where progress can be seen and communication continues is beneficial for both the employee and the employer.

The intricacies of how to handle claims is something you hope to never need to be good at as an employer, which is why it is so important to have a broker and claims advocate on your side to help navigate the process with you.

This is a complex topic and if you would like to discuss further or talk about any other insurance needs, I can be reached at (619)438-6900 or you can email me at ccraig@ranchomesa.com.

How to Strategically Grow Your Construction Company

Author, Casey Craig, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

One of the biggest ongoing challenges in the construction industry today is hiring and retaining quality employees that can help build on a company’s foundation. Growing a construction company in a sustainable way through internal promotions while also integrating new hires can separate one company from its competitors.

Employees are a company’s most valuable asset and making sure the right people are in the right positions is vital to profitable growth. There are high performing laborers at every construction firm but just because they are successful in one position does not necessarily mean that they will transition successfully into becoming a great estimator or superintendent. So, it is critical to promote the right people into the right positions for the success of the company.

Promoting from within is typically more cost effective than an outside hire and leads to a boost in company morale. The promoted employee already knows your company culture and safety expectations, and they can pass their knowledge onto new hires. So, finding the right internal people to elevate into leadership positions is the logical path, when available.  

Having assessment tests and specific steps for how to be promoted in your employee handbook is a great way to provide both new and seasoned employees a clear path for career growth.

Identify employees that can handle stressful situations and are poised problem solvers. Do not wait for a need to arise; start including these valued employees in meetings to make sure they are prepared to take on a new role when the company is ready to grow or there is an opening due to an employee retirement. This can alleviate some of a leader’s workload allowing them to deal with big picture issuing facing the firm.

Take advantage of both safety and professional development courses to grow your existing employees. Rancho Mesa’s SafetyOne™ platform provides online safety courses for employees, while the RM365 HRAdvantage™ Portal offers online courses to help employees hone the soft skills they will need to grow their careers.

While this topic remains one of the most challenging aspects of running a construction company, do not let this problem be compounded by being unprepared. Stay diligent in the hiring process and pay attention to the employees you do have with the right traits. This can lead to lower insurance costs as more efficient employees in management positions can directly assist with building a safer culture with more preparedness when claims arise.

If you have any questions pertaining to this article or any other insurance questions, do not hesitate to reach out. You can contact me at ccraig@ranchomesa.com or call at (619) 438-6900.

The Billion-Dollar Cost of Working at Height: The Critical Questions to Ask Before Climbing a Ladder

Author, Casey Craig, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Every year, OSHA publishes a “top 10 most frequently cited standards” list. Without question, ladders and fall protection consistently make the list. A Liberty Mutual 2023 workplace survey found that $6.26 billion was spent on falls as a result of working at height. Working at height is inherently dangerous but becomes more so when the incorrect ladders are used or improper setup for a job. Sending your employees to a jobsite without conducting a proper analysis to guarantee you have the proper equipment is setting yourself up to have preventable claims.

Before choosing a ladder at for a job, ask yourself:

• Will the ladders on site reach your desired height safely?

• Do the pads need to be replaced on the feet of the ladder?

• Do I have a faulty ladder?

• Should I be using fiberglass or metal?

• Is the ground level or should I have a ladder with adjustable outriggers?

• Do I need a guardrail system on my ladder?

• Am I able to get the proper angel needed for an extension ladder?

• Do my employees have the proper footwear?

All potential claims from ladders are theoretically preventable if we take the time to prepare properly. Your employees can be working at height for long periods of time, sometimes on very hot or cold days and need to be alert both while at height and especially when getting down. A vast majority of claims we see from ladder falls come from slipping or missing the last rung on a ladder. Looking further into these accident investigations, we see that many employees are not getting enough breaks so they can stay mentally and physically alert.

Most contractors are equipped with step stools, step ladders and extension ladders but these might not be all that is needed to get the job done properly. Each of these serve a purpose and are the most common on job sites for a reason which is why most work can be completed using just these three types of ladders. However, just because we are able to reach our desired height does not mean that it is the most efficient way to get there. Having more intricate ladders available for certain projects has become increasingly more valuable.

According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, fatal injuries from movable ladders has decreased by nearly 17% from 2019 to 2020 while non-fatal ladder injuries remained consistent (this is the newest data available published in April of 2022).  Things appear to be trending in the right direction with more information and safer ladders available. That said, ladder safety needs to be at the forefront of your safety program as those contractors working at height are always one slip away from a claim that can drastically change the live of an employee along with your insurance program.

If you have any questions on how to improve your ladder safety program or any other insurance questions, do not hesitate to reach out. You can contact me at ccraig@ranchomesa.com or call at (619) 438-6900.

Steering Towards Safety: Strategies for Lowering Commercial Auto Insurance Premiums

Author, Casey Craig, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

We are going into uncertain times as some commercial auto carriers are electing to no longer write new business in California. This is leading to other carriers, that are still willing, to be overwhelmed with requests for insurance quotes. Carriers are limited in the increases they can take from one policy period to the next and have had increasingly bad losses which have made it impossible to be profitable. This will lead to carriers inevitably charging more over time as the losses have become staggering. Let’s take a look at what you can do as an insured to help your company look like a better risk for these carriers and mitigate premium increases.

Increase Limits

Increase limits for employees that drive their personal vehicles. California’s minimum limits for auto insurance have not been raised in over 50 years. With vehicle costs and medical bills exponentially increasing over that time, it is easy to see how most drivers in California are underinsured if any serious accident occurs.

The Protect California Drivers Act will go into effect January 2025 which will increase the minimum personal auto insurance limits from $15,000/$30,000/$5,000 to $30,000/$60,000/$15,000. This will help Californians, but also consider increasing the limits your company requires for your employees. It will help insulate your company further and lead to more carriers potentially being willing to insure your company’s drivers.

Install GPS

Install GPS and have someone at the office track drivers. Insureds tend to use GPS as a reactive tool, if a vehicle goes missing they can track it and potentially recover. Or, if a driver gets a ticket, they look back to see if the driver was speeding or has an issue of speeding. If used properly, this can help your company find unsafe patterns before they lead to an accident. You can track speeding, hard turns, and excessive breaking. Being able to identify poor drivers before an accident happens can lead to substantial savings on your insurance premiums.

Implement Driver Training

Proactive and reactive driving trainings can go a long way. Rancho Mesa’s SafetyOne™ website offers online driver training. Driver training history is stored and available for review at any time. So, companies can prove to carriers they take driver safety training seriously.

Seeing where the industry is moving, it would be smart to ensure you are staying ahead of trends. Meeting with your insurance broker to make sure you have the proper fleet safety program in place is vital.

If you have any further insurance questions or would like to discuss your fleet safety program, please contact Casey Craig at (619) 438-6900 or ccraig@ranchomesa.com.

Implementing Best Practices when Hiring in the Construction Industry

Author, Casey Craig, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

With unemployment rates settling near 4%, it is becoming increasingly difficult to find the right employees to help grow your construction company. With most able-bodied workers having secure employment, this leads to having either apprentice-type employees that come with unique challenges or pulling from an aging workforce that can bring cumulative injuries and risks. Navigating these issues can be complex and there is not a perfect solution, but employer’s hiring practices need to change in order to keep up with the current state of the industry.

When hiring new employees, consider:

• Pre-hire drug testing

• Pre-hire physicals

• Targeted job postings with accurate description of daily work

• Multiple levels of interviews

• Simulating work at your office that potential new hires would be performing in the field

The US saw a unique shift in the workplace as a result of COVID-19 where employees felt their value skyrocket as fewer people were willing to work in-person. Employers were forced to increase wages to get bodies on jobsites. In prior years, it may have been enough to just rely on word of mouth and referrals to get new hires. Too often now, we are seeing new hires suffer “ghost injuries” that are quickly followed with letters of representation.  These and similar types of cumulative trauma claims can have long term impacts on your experience rating (EMR). While these situations are difficult to prevent, using best practices and conducting thorough interviews with your prospective employees will allow you to make educated decisions which typically lead to better hires.

Taking advantage of the best practices listed above can help insulate your company from poor hiring decisions. Obviously, we would love for new hires to turn into long term employees, as onboarding and proper training can be a costly expense in both other employee’s time and payroll. In a recent survey conducted by Traveler’s Insurance, it was shown that 34% of workplace injuries occurred during the worker’s first year on the job. This can be from a combination of inexperience, overexertion, and/or lack of safety knowledge.

Consider these hiring and onboarding processes to assist in mitigating the glaring number of claims that are emanating from newer employees or employees that have limited experience on jobsites. The financial impact they can have on your company will impact your balance sheet for years and can be potentially avoided with implementing some of our recommended techniques

To learn more about improving your hiring practices or how Rancho Mesa can help to improve your process, reach out at (619) 438-6900 or ccraig@ranchomesa.com.

Properly Utilizing Tailgate Meetings

Author, Casey Craig, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

For many foremen and superintendents, weekly tailgate meetings can feel like a task that just needs to be checked off the list. However, while the purpose of these meetings is critical for the health and well-being of fellow field employees, the time required and repetitive nature of them can create challenges. To maximize the benefits of these meetings, construction firms must be proactive and thoughtful as they develop an inventory of topics.

Identifying Tailgate Meeting Topics        

Take ample time with your sales team to understand the scope of your backlog to see where hazards may appear within these projects. Plan training topics with an eye on the weather, paying close attention to historically warm or cold months. Consider connecting with your insurance broker as well on recent injury trends that you can address with the crew.

This will be pertinent as your company approaches their renewal window with underwriters looking at claims history. They commonly ask, “what has the insured done to make sure these claims don’t happen again?” Learning from your past is key to being proactive. Knowing you will have certain exposures coming up and addressing those with preventative training topics begins to build a Best Practice Safety Program.

Accessing Content for Training

Locating “Toolbox” trainings can be time consuming and, in some cases, costly. And very often, the trainings may not be applicable to your operation and/or the trends you may need to focus on. With an eye to the future, Rancho Mesa has recently introduced a proprietary SafetyOne™ App. Safety managers will be able to document safety inspections from their mobile device and assign required fixes to employees, while also tracking when they have been completed. Meeting content can also be distributed to supervisors through their mobile device all with a focus of making safety meetings more efficient and effective. These same supervisors can now access a vast library that can be customized to their operation. 

Reach out to me to learn more about the SafetyOne™ App and how Rancho Mesa can partner with you and your team moving forward. You can reach me at (619) 438-6900 or email me at ccraig@ranchomesa.com

Construction Death Rate Not Decreasing as Expected

Author, Casey Craig, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

With the heightened safety regulations and OSHA guidelines over the past decade, many would think we are working in a much safer environment with fewer fatalities. Despite the rising number of employees and using a standard based off deaths per 100,000 employees, the data is showing that the number of fatalities are the same as they were a decade ago.

With a much larger workforce, OSHA is severely understaffed compared to the previous decade. The agency does not have enough inspectors to visit nearly enough jobsites. They have been more reactive in the sense that they are imposing fines on companies after they have had losses. These fines represent a fraction of what it would take to motivate construction companies to revamp their respective safety programs. Employers have factored these fines into the cost of business to a certain extent.

OSHA is now contemplating whether it is worth doubling the jobsite inspections annually and/or increase fines drastically. There is no solid data to link an increase in jobsite inspections to fewer fatalities, so the logical answer would be heavier fines and a push for more negligent death claims to be criminally prosecuted.

Either of these options will lead to more oversite or more fines for the construction industry as a whole. One critical approach you can take is to prepare yourself as a business owner. Be proactive. Consider working with the consultation branch of OSHA to visit your operation and jobsites. This division within OSHA does not issue fines or violations. They do, however, offer recommendations and advice on how to make your operation safer. With the potential of OSHA’s fines increasing, it is time to make sure that your company is on the forefront of safety. A great first step is reaching out to your insurance broker to help you meet requirements and push you to exceed. With a potential recession looming, it is important to make sure you have insulated your company from risk, so you have the best chance at thriving.

If you have any urgent questions on this topic, you can reach me directly at (619) 438-6900 or email me at ccraig@ranchomesa.com.

The Link Between Your EMR and Primary Threshold

Author, Casey Craig, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

One of the biggest concerns for contractors is their Experience Modification Rating (EMR). If your EMR exceeds 1.00 or 1.25, contractors can be removed from bid lists and premiums can escalate quickly. Most decision makers have little idea what factors contribute to the EMR and just how claims can impact them.

All construction companies are assigned class codes that best define their operations and those class codes have expected loss rates associated with them. The more losses that occur per $100 of payroll for that class code, the larger the expected loss rate will be. So, an electrician with a much lower expected loss rate than a roofing contractor will have each claim impact their EMR more. These are variables that can have a significant impact on your company’s EMR. The variable that fluctuates amongst each company is the amount of payroll they develop in each class code. The more payroll generated, the lower your best possible EMR can be.

Consequently, as a company’s best possible EMR decreases, the Primary Threshold increases. The Primary Threshold is a cap or threshold unique to each company. The higher the primary threshold, the less that any one claim can impact your EMR. For example, a painting contractor using the 5474 class code and averaging $200,000 a year in payroll will have a best possible EMR of 83 and primary threshold of only $8,500. Each claim has the potential of contributing 40 points to their EMR. While another painter that averages $10,000,000 in payroll will have a best possible EMR of 41 and primary threshold of $49,000. Thus, the maximum any one claim can impact the company with higher payroll is just 5 points.

This certainly is a drastic difference but it makes sense as the larger company has more employees which leads to more exposure and more expected losses. The component that most companies do not know well enough is that for each company in the examples above, the WCIRB penalizes the exact same for any claim that exceeds your primary threshold. So, for the smaller company, an $8,500 claim is worth 40 points to their EMR, a $1,000,000 claim is worth the exact same amount. And, the same for the larger company with a $49,000 claim worth 5 points but any claim dollars in excess of that will not impact the EMR.

Taking this information into account, we urge our clients to focus on mitigating claims before they happen as well as doing their best to reduce contributing factors such as temporary disability. Having your carrier pay for your employees missed time leads to your EMR increasing and your premiums inevitably being higher than you would like.

Understanding and implementing a return-to-work program is extremely beneficial to your company and leads to you saving money over time. Working with your broker to better understand how to properly handle claims and making sure you are doing everything possible to keep your EMR as low as possible is vital to your company’s profitability and is very much in your control.

Everyone wants a better EMR and lower premiums but the elite contractors are active in not only preventing claims from happening but understanding how important it is to keep their employees at the workplace, or at the very least, off the couch at home.

If you would like to learn more about your firm’s primary threshold or how it is impacting your company, please do not hesitate to reach out to me directly at ccraig@ranchomesa.com or call me at (619) 438-6900. 

Staying Ahead of the “Hard Market”

Author, Casey Craig, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Over the past 15+ quarters, California employers have been experiencing a soft workers’ compensation marketplace. At some point, however, this will start to pivot and the companies that will secure the more favorable pricing must be able to differentiate themselves to their insurance carriers. As we continue seeing signs of the hard market coming, without this solid explicit differentiation, it will become harder for our carriers to be aggressive with their pricing. With all of that said, as a business owner, you may be asking how you differentiate yourself to the insurance marketplace and protect your company from large premium increases. Following are some proven methods.

Return to Work Programs

Do you have a return to work program in place? We all would like to prevent injuries from occurring but need effective return to work programs to help control the total cost of a claim after it has occurred. The fewer dollars that are paid in temporary disability can directly save points on your experience modification (MOD), lower your overall loss ratio, and reduce litigation. All three of these benefits will help you in the marketplace and keep future premiums in check. Watch our “Return to Work Program: A Cost Effect Solution” webinar to learn more about these types of programs.

Hiring Practices

Take an in-depth look at your hiring practices. Many employers are experiencing an uptick in post termination claims that can turn into cumulative trauma claims. This can have severe impacts on your MOD and loss ratio, so it’s vital that you are bringing on the right employees. Pre-hire physicals and drug testing, formal interviews, checking references and job offers with job descriptions are great ways to make sure you are onboarding the right people who are clear in what is expected of them. Fraudulent claims consistently arise from employees who feel undervalued, underpaid, or underappreciated. Hire people with defined roles and make sure they are acknowledged when they are performing well. Employees who are consistently recognized by management and have strong relationships with their supervisors are less likely to file fraudulent claims. Use our Job Description Builder to quickly create job descriptions within the RM365 HRAdvantage™ Portal.

Provide and Document Safety Trainings

Utilize training materials that are provided by your insurance broker. As the hard market trend continues, it is going to be even more important to show the carrier that you are preemptively stopping claims from happening by actively training your employees. Showing your carrier partner that your employees are properly trained and management is prepared when claims occurs will go a long way to getting you the savings you deserve. Rancho Mesa has developed the RM365 Advantage Safety Star™ certification program for foreman/supervisors that is endorsed by the insurance marketplace as a way to both raise the level of safety awareness but also provide subjective credits to your premiums. Rancho Mesa also provides many additional training materials and workshops through our Risk Management Center for clients to use in conducting and documenting their safety.  

Now is the time to make sure that you are taking the necessary steps to differentiate yourself from your peers. As you look forward, consider Rancho Mesa and our myriad of resources to help start that process. Contact me at ccraig@ranchomesa.com or (619) 438-6900.

How Higher Average Pay Can Lead to Work Comp Savings

Author, Casey Craig, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Wage thresholds have increased consistently in the past decade. This has pushed owners to give sizable raises every few years to maximize employee compensation, but also reducing insurance cost. The experience modification (XMOD) and payrolls are key factors in developing a company’s net rates for workers’ compensation, but average wage per hour represents a big differentiator for most carriers and can lead to even more savings.

Paying your most competent employees above the wage threshold leads to less fraudulent claims, longer tenured employees, and a happier workplace, not to mention the benefit of a drastic cut in net rates for that class code. The gap that is sometimes felt is when there are employees that have the same job description and are earning 30-40% less. Managing payroll inflation is always critical for businesses but let’s think about what this can do to the employees bringing the average pay down for your company. Consider:

• More fraudulent claims as the employee has less to lose if they are terminated or laid off;

• Resentment toward employees that are doing same job but making more;

• Employees are more likely to move to another company to get raises;

• Likelihood to miss more time when injured, leading toward higher temporary disability pay which typically can lead to a higher XMOD.

Insurance companies and their underwriters look closely at average salary per employee when they receive a submission with the renewal documentation.

The higher the average pay, the more aggressive they can be with potential scheduled credits in most cases. Obviously, the employer must be selective with who receives a raise and how much but also understand what potentially positive impacts there can be when giving raises in order to hit those thresholds.

And, perhaps just as important is partnering with a broker that specializes in your industry and knows how to properly benchmark you with like organizations. This consistently leads to more productive discussions with underwriters that lead to more scheduled credits. The happier your workforce is, the less claims you tend to see and that translates to long-term savings.

If you have any questions about how you compare to your industry or would like to discuss any other insurance related topic, do not hesitate to reach out to 619-937-0164 or email me directly at ccraig@ranchomesa.com.

Wage Inflation’s Impact On Workers’ Compensation

Author, Casey Craig, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Following up on a great article by fellow construction team member Kevin Howard, about anticipated wage threshold increases coming in 2022, I wanted to highlight the building problems resulting from substantial hourly wage increases.

I specialize in painting, drywall and plastering contractors and have been asking my clients over the past few months about the health of their business and any new challenges. The most common answer: there is a substantial amount of work to bid on, but a labor shortage limits the possibility of growth.

Paying an employee higher wages creates new issues. Employees tend to inform co-workers when they get a raise. Employees may also try to leverage another company’s higher wage into a raise. The combination of a labor shortage and overpaying employees may result in hyperinflation, leading these employees to believe their value has skyrocketed.

Tying back into Kevin’s article, it is easy to see why these thresholds need to be increased. The wage threshold is meant to separate historically safer employees from newer employees who are less safety conscious. These increases in payroll are pushing less skilled employees into the higher wage category, resulting very likely in higher claim frequency as they are historically less experienced and safety conscious on the jobsite. This is leading to a smaller gap in workers’ compensation rates between the above and below class codes for each industry.

For example, a painter had a separation of 56% from 5474 to 5482 (painters making above or below $28) for their 2021 renewal. For 2022, they are only looking at a 46% difference. From the carrier perspective, more losses are expected in the 5482 (above $28) than the previous year, leading to a rate increase in that class code. I wish I could say that this was industry specific, but from conversations with multiple underwriters, most industries are dealing with these same employment issues and have struggled to find meaningful solutions.

It is possible these dual wage threshold increases will help restore balance by bringing the less skilled employees back into the proper class code, securing the lower rates in the over class code. Employers have shared that these threshold increases are hurting them, but should assist with workers’ comp savings for the truly elite seasoned workers. Carriers have these thresholds to help you differentiate experience from inexperience.

This is a developing issue that we are trying to stay ahead of. The time is now to meet with someone who specializes in your industry and help you formulate a strategy for 2022 to mitigate these impacts and improve your profitably. To schedule a time to talk or meet with me or you can call me directly at 619-438-6900.

Pure Premium and How It Impacts Your Company

Author, Casey Craig, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

The Workers’ Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau (WCIRB) is an agency that compiles essential data annually which determines how your Experience MOD is impacted. These factors establish the baseline average MOD of 1.00 for California companies that produce enough payroll and premium to qualify within the guidelines. These factors can change year to year and represent a key rate trend indicator for all policyholders.

There are different rates generated for different classifications based on exposure and projected losses. The premium company’s pay for workers' compensation begins with multiplying the insurer's rate for the assigned classification(s) by the payroll developed in each classification. Workers' compensation rates are applied per $100 of payroll.

Pulling directly from the WCIRB website, “The WCIRB submits advisory pure premium rates to the California Department of Insurance (CDI) for approval. Insurer rates are usually derived from the advisory pure premium rates developed by the WCIRB and approved by the Insurance Commissioner. Advisory pure premium rates, expressed as a rate per $100 of payroll, are based upon loss and payroll data submitted to the WCIRB by all insurance companies. These rates reflect the amount of losses an insurer can expect to pay in benefits due to workplace injuries as well as the cost for adjusting and settling workers' compensation claims. Pure premium rates do not account for administrative and other overhead costs that an insurer will incur and, consequently, an insurer's rates are typically higher than the pure premium rates.” (WCIRB).

Of note, new pure premium rates were just released in September. Each carrier’s individual experience with all respective class codes also has an impact on these rates. Workers’ compensation has been in a soft market for the past several years with the expectation that rates will gradually start increasing. Following the change in pure premium rates is a great indication of where the marketplace is heading an effective way to better understand future costs that your company may be expecting.

With this in mind, engaging a broker that specializes in your industry and prepares you accordingly for the renewal process is a critical step in controlling workers compensation costs. Part of this process begins with understanding pure premium rates and how they ultimately will impact your MOD, carrier base rates, and your renewal pricing.

To discuss the current market or how your XMOD is affecting your workers’ compensation premium, contact me at (619) 438-6900 or ccraig@ranchomesa.com.

ANSI Releases New Mobile Elevating Work Platforms Standards

Author, Casey Craig, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Last year, the American National Standards Institute (ANSI) updated their aerial lift standard, starting with renaming it Mobile Elevating Work Platforms (MEWP). This has been in the works since 2018 and is designed to align training, certifications, and equipment used on a more universal standard. According to the Center for Construction Research and Training (CPWR), roughly 26 people die from MEWP each year. This prompted the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) to increase training requirements to keep accidents to a minimum. Obviously, MEWP are essential for completing a wide variety of construction jobs. So, what should you, as a business owner, be doing to ensure your employees are safe and in compliance when OSHA comes by your jobsites?

MEWP are prone to tipping over on uneven ground and in inclement weather conditions, if equipment is extended out. The most common cause of the MEWP tipping over is driving it over uneven surfaces. Understandably, many contractors rush to complete projects but moving extended lifts can be the easiest way to have a serious accident. Alternatively, taking proper time to lower a lift before moving it leads to fewer serious accidents.

Identifying exposures and objects that conflict with a lift’s surroundings is also of great concern for lift operators. A very common occurrence involves employees being pinned between the lift and an object. It is easy to become fixated on either the ground or the direction the lift is moving and ”miss” objects that could be hazardous as you are raising and lowering the lift. Allowing for time to plan ahead and move the machinery safely is immensely important.

Many of these new requirements are focused on teaching proper equipment use and creating an awareness of the changes to new equipment in the marketplace. Inherently, these machines are dangerous but necessary. So, maintaining a respect for them and understanding how to properly use them is vital. Lift use trainings, techniques, and protocol are available through our Risk Management Center and are compliant with the new ANSI/SAIA A92.20, A92.22, and A92.24 standards that were just released, last year.

Please reach out to me at ccraig@ranchomesa.com or call at 619-937-0164 for more information, or for help assigning the trainings.

Implementing an Effective Fall Safety Program Can Have Serious Impacts

Author, Casey Craig, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Year after year, falls are among the leading type of workers’ compensation claims and generate the highest claim costs. They account for multiple infractions on the top 10 most frequently cited standards, according to the Occupational Safety and Health Administration. How can you, as a business owner, control your exposure and keep your employees productive and healthy?

Prevention

According to the Centers for Disease Control, “27% of the 900,380 nonfatal work injuries resulting in days away from work in 2018 were related to slips, trips, and falls.” That’s a shockingly large number especially when 100% of falls are preventable if you take the time to plan, according to the National Safety Council (NSC). The NSC recommends:

• Walking a job before employees get there to ensure proper set up is achievable with the equipment you are bringing for that job.

• Pay attention to environmental conditions such as wind, rain, or excessive heat.

• Check your equipment frequently to ensure nothing is worn down or damaged.

• Make sure employees are wearing the proper foot wear and other Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) items required for the individual job needs.

Having employees working on ladders or scaffolding is essential for some jobs, and fortunately is a risk you can control. In addition to evaluating the work site, the equipment, the environmental factors, and PPE needed, you should also evaluate the health and fitness of all employees. Factors to consider should include the employee’s:

• Experience

• Fitness level

• Age

Height Matters

A fatal fall can happen at almost any height. According to the NSC, only 16% of fatal falls in 2016 occurred as a result of a fall from over 30 feet; however, 53% of fatal falls that year resulted from below 20 feet. Given this data, best practices would dictate that construction companies should step back and reevaluate the safety procedures they have in place and determine if any changes need to be made, particularly for jobs that are considered the lower heights.

RM365 Advantage Safety Star™ Program

To get your employees properly trained, we recommend enrolling in our RM365 Advantage Safety Star™ program that includes Fall Prevention training. This program includes fundamental safety topics that allows your foreman or key management team to go through internet-based safety trainings and earn their Safety Star certification. This program has shown to improve safety while helping to reduce your workers’ compensation premiums. Register to start your RM365 Advantage Safety Star™ program, today.

Rancho Mesa understands the exposure our clients face on a daily basis and can help implement safety procedures to mitigate these risks. Underestimating a project’s risk or undertraining employees is an exposure you can address.

If you would like help in reviewing your safety protocols and procedures or if you have further questions, do not hesitate to reach out to me at (619) 438-6900 or email me at ccraig@ranchomesa.com.

Profitable Bids Should Include Often Overlooked Insurance Costs

Author, Casey Craig, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

We will take a look at factors that go into your bid and ways to ensure you are hitting your target profit margin.

There are many factors that go into creating a profitable bid on a construction project. They include:

• The scope of the work

• The location of the project

• Material costs

• Labor costs

For most construction companies, their estimators are well versed in all of the areas mentioned earlier and yet despite their best efforts, an unforeseen circumstance may occur and drive up the cost of a project, resulting in reduced profitability or a loss on the project.

One area that is often overlooked, but controllable, is the impact insurance has on the profitability of the project. The question to ask is how prepared are you and your staff to address the following questions:

Do you have the required insurance, coverages, limits, and terms in place to meet the contractual requirements of the project? If not, what will be the cost to add those requirements?

Will the project overlap your insurance renewal? If so, what changes in your Experience Modification Rate (EMR) can you anticipate and what will be the dollar impact?

What changes in your General Liability and Excess Insurance rates can you expect? 

Working with your insurance advisor on the above is a necessary step is helping to create a better opportunity for profitable jobs. At Rancho Mesa, we follow strict Best Practices and have prescheduled meetings with our insureds throughout the policy term, but additionally conduct a focused pre-renewal meeting 120 days prior to policy expiration.

Those meetings allow us to:

• Keep our clients aware of changes in the insurance marketplace that may impact their business.

• Project their EMR for the coming year and discuss how this might influence your bidding process.

• Review industry workers’ compensation trends in both Pure Premium Rates and Expected Loss Rates and their impact on workers compensation costs.

So, work with your insurance advisor and uncover those overlooked insurance costs to minimize risk and maximize profitability. To understand these factors in more detail or to look at our new KPI Dashboard that puts this information at your fingertips you can reach me at 619-486-6900 or ccraig@ranchomesa.com.

The Importance of Timely Workers’ Compensation Claims Reporting

Author, Casey Craig, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Injuries, accidents, and mistakes happen. When a work-related injury occurs, a common reaction from many business owners is an instinct to NOT report the injury to their workers’ compensation carrier for fear of increasing their company’s Experience Modification (EMR). However, they couldn’t be more wrong. Timely reporting of all claims is the first step in controlling claim costs and lowering their EMR.

Best Practices would demand that all claims get reported within 24 hours, if at all possible. By doing this, it provides the best possible outcome and will impact the claim in several positive ways:

Reducing Fraudulent Claims

One of the biggest frustrations in the workers’ compensation industry for most employers are the number of fraudulent claims that find their way into the system. Immediate accident investigation, witness statements and pictures followed by reporting the claim to the carrier within 24 hours of the injury, will give the employer and the carrier the best opportunity to deny a claim. The insurance carrier only has 90 days from the date of injury (not from the date reported) to deny a claim. This shortens that time-frame and allows more fraudulent claims into the system.

Lowering Litigation Rates

Another area employers find both frustrating and costly are the number of litigated claims that occur within the workers’ compensation system. Litigated claims on average will add 30% to 35% to the ultimate cost of a claim. While there are many ways employers can impact this area, perhaps the most controllable is the timely reporting of any injury. To further support this, it has been proven that the litigation rate for claims goes up 300% if the claim is reported 5 or more days after the injury occurred.

Identifying Claim Trends Early

By not reporting all claims or by reporting them late, employers can develop unreliable data in their effort to identify claim trends and root causes. Without this information, businesses in all sectors run the risk of a severe injury occurring from an area that could have been addressed if all claim data was accurate and analyzed.

When an injury occurs, do a thorough accident investigation that details all events that caused the injury and immediately call your workers’ compensation carrier. This one habit alone will help you lower claim costs and manage your EMR.

To learn more about this process, including benchmarking and analytics that can help control your loss ratio and lower premiums, please reach out to me, Casey Craig at (619) 438-6900 or ccraig@ranchomesa.com.

Nurse Triage Can Save You Time and Money

Author, Casey Craig, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

When dealing with minor injuries, one of the last places you want your employees having to go right now is to a clinic or hospital emergency room. What are ways that you can keep your employees well cared for, without subjecting them to the added exposure of a waiting room? Telephonic Nurse Triage allows your employee to have a conversation with a registered nurse and possibly avoid the trip to a clinic or emergency room.

The advantages of using nurse triage include:

• Timely Claim Reporting

• Quick Proper Treatment          

• Improved Productivity

• Lower Claim Costs

• Reduced Litigation

The average call to a nurse triage provider is 8-12 minutes, which includes the introductory questions. This process can save your company countless hours while still getting your employee the proper care needed. Additionally, should the injured employee require further care, the nurse can help direct the employee to the nearest approved clinic or hospital within your insurance provider’s Medical Provider Network (MPN).

Nurse Triage has developed into a much needed resource in the workers’ compensation field. Recognizing this, some insurance carriers have begun integrating this service into their own claims management process. At Rancho Mesa, educating our clients on options and resources like these help us stay on the leading edge of technology. If you would like assistance in exploring Nurse Triage or other cost saving programs, please contact Alyssa Burley, Client Services Manager, at aburley@ranchomesa.com.

Generating Your Employee Handbook Is Easier Than Keeping a New Years Resolution

Author, Casey Craig, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

When business owners are asked if their employee handbooks are up to date, they typically shrug and say “It’s something we have been meaning to tackle.” It is hard to blame them when it often feels as though a newly revised employee handbook quickly requires an update due to changes in employment laws! There is a significant need for an easy to use option where employers can have an up to date handbook throughout the year and, have it generated at no cost. Rancho Mesa provides that solution.

As the California workplace climate changes, it is imperative that business owners have solutions before problems arise. Employee lawsuits against their employers are on the rise and Rancho Mesa clients must be prepared for the possible, if not inevitable. While updating an employee handbook can be one of the easiest obligations to neglect, skipping this task can have serious repercussions.

When laws and protocols change over time, it can be difficult making sure your employee handbook is up to date. Make sure it clearly communicates:

• What is expected of your employees.

• What are your company policies.

• What rules are in place.

At Rancho Mesa, we have taken the time to understand our clients’ needs and if there is a solution available, we try to accommodate. We provide a free option for our clients, to help them compose a compliant handbook that is:

• State and federal compliant.

• Handbook is fully customizable with optional policy update alerts. If a law were to change right after completing your handbook, you would receive an email with the change and have the option to add it to your handbook.

• Live HR support to assist with company specific question.

Please reach out to Alyssa Burley at aburley@ranchomesa.com with any questions you may have about the employee handbook builder option through the RM365 HRAdvantage™ portal. If you have any questions pertaining to your insurance needs, please call (619) 934-0164.