Industry News

News, Human Services, Risk Management Guest User News, Human Services, Risk Management Guest User

Four Factors Contributing to Employee Theft

Author, Sam Brown, Vice President of Human Services, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Crime insurance policies act as one line of defense against financial loss to an employer. At times, guarding against theft can feel like an uphill battle with many factors outside of our control. One common form of crime insurance claims may be more preventable than ever with some quick education. We are talking about employee theft.

Author, Sam Brown, Vice President of Human Services, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Crime insurance policies act as one line of defense against financial loss to an employer. At times, guarding against theft can feel like an uphill battle with many factors outside of our control. One common form of crime insurance claims may be more preventable than ever with some quick education. We are talking about employee theft.

Employee theft can come in the form of stolen petty cash, liberal use of gas cards, or payroll fraud. A review and understanding of the most common reasons why employees steal from their employer can help prevent such crimes.

1. Financial Need

Real or perceived, a financial crisis can drive an employee to steal. Examples include family illness, falling behind on bills, personal debts, or even the desire to have clothing or material possessions the employee cannot afford on their own.

2. Perceived Unfair Treatment

Employees justify stealing when they believe the employer has overworked and underpaid its employees. An employee may also blame management when job performance does not warrant a pay increase. Employees may feel the company owes them.

3. Opportunity

One theory suggests that even honest people will steal if there is ample opportunity. It would make sense then that the incidence of theft increases for employees near unsecured cash or valuable property. This is especially true for employees who understand the worth of company property.

4. Workplace Norms

Employees who see co-workers get away with stealing from the company are more likely to commit theft themselves. Conversely, a quick reminder to a new employee that theft of an any kind is not condoned can adequately communicate what is and what is not to be tolerated.

Understanding factors that drive an employee to steal from an employer can help organizational leaders identify suspicious behavior. This may also lead to management decisions made to influence company culture in a positive way.

Please contact Rancho Mesa Insurance if your private company or non-profit organization has questions about crime insurance and employee theft.

Read More

Automobile Rental Reimbursement for Tree Care Companies

Author, Rory Anderson, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

A tree care company’s auto fleet includes specialty vehicles like bucket and box trucks. These vehicles are important assets for the company and critical for completing jobs. Getting into an auto accident is already stressful, but what can add more grief is if the vehicle that gets damaged is vital for your business. In this case, you will be looking to rent a replacement vehicle during the repair window so that your business can maintain productivity and profitability. With this in mind, rental reimbursement coverage helps cover the rental cost incurred while your vehicle is repaired after a covered loss.

Author, Rory Anderson, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

A tree care company’s auto fleet includes specialty vehicles like bucket and box trucks. These vehicles are important assets for the company and critical for completing jobs. Getting into an auto accident is already stressful, but what can add more grief is if the vehicle that gets damaged is vital for your business. In this case, you will be looking to rent a replacement vehicle during the repair window so that your business can maintain productivity and profitability. With this in mind, rental reimbursement coverage helps cover the rental cost incurred while your vehicle is repaired after a covered loss.

In the tree care business, renting a specialty truck is no easy task. Rental bucket and box trucks are expensive and limited. Renting these specialty trucks can cost up to $600 per day. In addition to the cost, the COVID-19 pandemic continues to cause problems with the supply chain of products, including auto parts. So, not only is it expensive to rent these specialty trucks, but it is also taking longer than normal to get vehicles repaired.

The standard rental reimbursement coverage will offer between $50 and $100 per day for 30 days. With how costly the tree care specialty trucks are and with the amount of time it is taking to repair these trucks, you can see how you might find yourself in a sticky situation if one of these key trucks goes down. However, certain insurance carriers will offer to increase the per day amount as well as extend the period of rental reimbursement coverage, if needed.

Partnering with an insurance professional who specializes in the tree care industry is important to make sure that your bucket and box trucks have the correct rental reimbursement coverage in the case of an auto accident.

To discuss this potential gap within your current insurance program or any other commercial insurance for your tree care business, contact me at (619) 486-6437 or randerson@ranchomesa.com.

Read More

Three Changes to Your Routine That Increases Safety

Author, Greg Garcia, Account Executive, Landscape Group, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Every landscape company wants to be safe. So, I want to discuss three ways to improve safety in your workplace starting today: routine equipment maintenance, personal protective equipment (PPE) checks, and finally, assessing job site hazards.

Author, Greg Garcia, Account Executive, Landscape Group, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Every landscape company wants to be safe. So, I want to discuss three ways to improve safety in your workplace, starting today.

1) Routine Equipment Maintenance

Routine maintenance and cleaning of equipment is essential for any landscape company wanting to make sure all of their equipment is running properly and is ready for a day’s work. From a safety standpoint, we see the biggest risk comes from those companies who use sprayers to fertilize lawns and plants for their clients. By not cleaning the sprayers out daily, landscape companies are putting their employees at risk of being exposed to pesticides and herbicides, which can be detrimental to the employee’s heath. Therefore, routinely checking and cleaning pieces of equipment can not only improve your productivity and profitability by making sure equipment is ready for work, but can also lead to a much safer working environment for your employees.

2) personal protective equipment (PPE) checks

Personal protective equipment is one of the most important things landscape employees can use to protect themselves while they work. Whether it be thorny bushes to cut back, the use of loud chainsaws or mowers, or just the effects of being out in the sun, it is important to assess the job site hazards and make proper PPE choices. A few examples that landscape companies are doing to help their employees fight the effects of being exposed to the sun are: wearing long sleeve shirts, wearing sun hats that provide shade to the face and neck, and wearing proper sunglasses to help with the heavy glare. Always keeping up to date and staying informed on proper PPE will ensure that your landscape company is doing all they can to stay safe.

3) assessing job site hazards

Finally, addressing job site hazards is vital for companies in the landscape industry. The safety manager, supervisor or foreman need to get out to job sites and really see what hazards are out there. For example, look to see if there are any poisonous plants at the jobsite and/or any pieces of debris or puddles in the walk ways that could create a trip and fall hazard. All of these exposures need to be noted to ensure everyone is aware of potential risks. Every jobsite is different, so it is crucial that your team remain proactive and really hone in on the potential risks at each particular jobsite.

If equipment checks, PPE checks, and job site checks are not currently in your landscape company’s safety routine, I would strongly suggest starting that routine, today.

Subscribe to our weekly landscape-specific safety emails to ensure you are getting relevant training materials every week.

If you have questions about how to mitigate your company’s risk, reach out to Greg Garcia at (619) 438-6905 or ggarcia@ranchomesa.com.

Read More
News, Risk Management Guest User News, Risk Management Guest User

Is Your Business Safe From a Business Email Compromise Claim?

Author, Jeremy Hoolihan, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Cybercrimes are at an all-time high. News sources report cybercrimes almost on a daily basis with most of the press relating to company breaches and cyber extortion. However, one of the biggest cyber threats that is often overlooked is Business Email Compromise (BEC).

Author, Jeremy Hoolihan, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Cybercrimes are at an all-time high. News sources report cybercrimes almost on a daily basis with most of the press relating to company breaches and cyber extortion. However, one of the biggest cyber threats that is often overlooked is Business Email Compromise (BEC).

BEC is a type of email cybercrime scam in which an attacker targets a business to defraud the company. BEC attacks use real or impersonated business email accounts to defraud employees. In 2020, BEC scammers made over $1.8 billion – far more than any other type of cybercrime.

In this type of cybercrime, the scammer sends an email that looks like it came from someone the recipient knows, like a superior or co-worker, and asks them to do perform a task. For example, the email may request:

  • A change to a vendor’s mailing address so future payments are sent to the scammer and not to the actual vendor.

  • An employee to purchase gift cards for a charity auction or employee rewards and then asks for the serial numbers on the cards so the scammers can use them without ever having the physical card.

  • A client is sent an email with wire instructions for payment of an invoice that appears to come from your company, but instead it is for the scammer’s bank account.

BEC scams use a variety of impersonation techniques. The following 3 techniques tend to be the most common:

  • A spoofed email address or website often has a slight variation from the legitimate address or URL. At a quick glance, the spoofed email address may fool victims into thinking it’s authentic. However, upon a closer look, an “L” might be switched out for a “I” or an “0” for an “o.”

  • Phishing emails appear to come from a trusted sender in order to trick the victim into providing personal or confidential information like account numbers, usernames, personal identification numbers, passwords or answers to security questions. Then, the information is used to gain access to networks, accounts, and other data.

  • Cyber criminals can infiltrate a company’s network using malicious software and gain access to networks and legitimate emails, often getting information about billing and invoices. This type of cybercrime is often unnoticed until it is too late.

For ways on how to protect your business from BEC claims, Rancho Mesa recommends first starting with a Cyber Liability policy. A comprehensive Cyber Liability policy will not only respond to BEC claims, but it can also provide coverage for other cybercrimes such as cyber extortion, cyber breach, and network security. If you have an interest in obtaining a Cyber Liability policy please feel free to reach out to me at 619-937-0174 or jhoolihan@ranchomesa.com.

Read More

Signing Up for Safety

Author, Greg Garcia, Account Executive, Landscape Group, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

There are many tips, ideas, and systems involved in creating a safe culture in the landscape industry. The most common practice landscape companies implement with regards to safety are regular safety meetings.

Author, Greg Garcia, Account Executive, Landscape Group, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

There are many tips, ideas, and systems involved in creating a safe culture in the landscape industry. The most common practice landscape companies implement with regards to safety are regular safety meetings.

For these meetings to be effective, you need to ask yourself three questions:

  1. What should be discussed during these safety meetings?

  2. How often do we really need to have these meetings?

  3. Where can I find content for these meetings?

Let’s take a look at each question in more detail. 

What should be discussed in these safety meetings? The easy answer is we will just talk about an accident that has recently occurred. That seems like a good approach, but it’s more of a reactive approach than proactive. Make no mistake about it, it is very important to go over safety regarding a previous incident, and take the necessary steps to help prevent that incident from happening again.  However, a great safety culture includes a more proactive approach by covering safety topics before an incident occurs.  Examples of good topics for safety meetings include something as simple as “Operating a Leaf Blower” to more pressing issues like “Handling Medical Emergencies and Jobsite Injuries.”

Secondly, how often do we need to hold these meetings? The quick answer as often as possible, but we recommend weekly safety meetings as they are the best way to create and change culture for the better. Weekly meetings build consistency. And, these good habits create a safety first culture by emphasizing safety and showing your employees that their wellbeing is a top priority. Plus, OSHA requires safety meetings at least every ten working days, so scheduling them weekly ensures you are meeting that requirement.

Finally, and what seems to be the most important question, is where can I find content for these safety meetings? Rancho Mesa wants to help provide that content. We publish a weekly landscape specific safety tailgate email. These emails arrive in your inbox every Tuesday and range from proper equipment use like “Avoiding Mower-Related Injuries,” to specific injury topics such as “Preventing Heat-Related Illness.” Our 52-week tailgate topics are not only landscape specific, but they correspond to the seasons, as well. So, you will not be receiving a topic on Heat Illness in the middle of winter, instead that topic is more likely to come out in the summer months. There are both English and Spanish versions of these tailgate topics that can be downloaded. These safety emails are something that our clients are taking full advantage of, and is a great way to take the burden of finding landscape specific safety topics off your plate, every week.

In an effort to serve and support the overall health and safety of the landscape community, we offer these trainings without charge to any landscape company that is interested in receiving them. Sign up to receive these trainings every week.

If you have any questions or would like more assistance in developing your safety program, contact me at 619-438-6905 or email me at ggarcia@ranchomesa.com.

Read More
Construction, OSHA, Risk Management Guest User Construction, OSHA, Risk Management Guest User

Understanding the DART and TCIR Calculations

Author, Lauren Stumpf, Media Communications and Client Services Specialist, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

When a project owner asks you to provide the company’s DART or TCIR rate, it may seem a little overwhelming at first. But, the two numbers are really a score that can be used to compare contractors’ safety history. These numbers can be important during the bidding process when comparing multiple bids and could be a determining factor for who is awarded the contract.

Author, Lauren Stumpf, Media Communications and Client Services Specialist, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

When a project owner asks you to provide the company’s DART or TCIR rate, it may seem a little overwhelming at first. But, the two numbers are really a score that can be used to compare contractors’ safety history. These numbers can be important during the bidding process when comparing multiple bids and could be a determining factor for who is awarded the contract.

DART stands for days away, restricted, or transferred. A DART rate is used to track any OSHA recordable workplace injury or illness that result in days away from work, restricted duty, or transfer of duties.

On the other hand, the TCIR is the total case incident rate (also known as the Total Recordable Incident Rate or sometimes referred to as the OSHA Incident Rate). It measures a company's past safety performance based on their incident rate. A TCIR is found by looking at the number of work-related injuries per 100 full-time workers during a one-year period.

The TCIR will likely be higher than the DART because it includes all incidents, not just the ones that results in lost time.

Project owners are increasingly requesting these numbers along with the project bid. Not only do they want to see how much it’s going to cost them to build the project, but they want to know how safe their contractor is on the jobsite. These numbers show that.

OSHA also uses these calculations to monitor high-risk industries.

Rancho Mesa’s Risk Management Center features a tool that helps contractors generate their DARTs and TCIRs. Contractors can use the Incident Track application to enter and track an incident’s details. Once that incident has been saved, the system will allow them to generate OSHA logs based on that data and generate the DART and TCIR.

“It’s an easy-to-use tool that ensures the numbers are accurate and available whenever they’re needed,” said Alyssa Burley, Media Communications and Client Services Manager with Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

To learn more about the Risk Management Center’s capabilities, sign up for an upcoming webinar at www.ranchomesa.com/workshops-and-webinars.

Read More
News, Construction, Risk Management Guest User News, Construction, Risk Management Guest User

Artisans Captive – Risk Control Workshop Recap

Author, Amber Webb, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

On January 20th and 21st of 2022, Captive Resources hosted the Artisans Captive Risk Control Workshop at The US Grant in San Diego, CA. The workshop was intended for all Artisans’ risk and/or safety mangers, human resources, claims managers, supervisors, owners, brokers and any others who wished to attend.

Author, Amber Webb, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

On January 20th and 21st of 2022, Captive Resources hosted the Artisans Captive Risk Control Workshop at The US Grant in San Diego, CA. The workshop was intended for all Artisans’ risk and/or safety mangers, human resources, claims managers, supervisors, owners, brokers and any others who wished to attend.

The workshop began with a brief introduction to the members of Captive Resources and Zurich Insurance Group, along with quick summaries of each of their responsibilities. Then, immediately following was an overview of how the captive is operated and how each member company can earn points which ultimately contribute towards the calculation of their year-end dividend. The group was able to hear from Rich McElhaney from The Real Cost of Safety, as the keynote speaker on the 20th. His story was captivating and eye opening to just how quick something can go wrong on a jobsite without the proper safety protocols in place. He stressed the importance of getting supervisors and employees to report their near misses. Each time a near miss is reported, it gives the company an opportunity to do a training and possibly make changes to their safety policies and procedures to avoid future incidents. Reporting near misses also gives companies a chance to look at areas where trends are taking place and make the appropriate adjustments.

The first day of the workshop ended with dinner and a tour of the USS Midway. This was a great time for member companies to network and chat about what each other are doing with regard to their risk control and safety programs.

The second day of the workshop on the 21st, we all met early for breakfast which also allowed for more networking and learning about different member companies. Immediately after breakfast, we all broke out into our different session groups to learn about specific topics. The first session focused on the, “Do’s & Don’ts of Accident Investigation.” In this session, we went over a twelve-step process for what to do when there is an accident on the job. We were given several great tips for what to do and what not to do. One recommendation was to take pictures of all four corners of your vehicle, then all four sides and repeat for all other vehicles at the scene. The presenter also encouraged not using the phrase, “no comment” if the media becomes involved. Instead, showing empathy and compassion while still not commenting can lead to a better outcome while the investigation is still ongoing. Another takeaway from this session was the importance of reviewing all of your policies to ensure they do not stress productivity over safety. Then, make sure to train your employees to understand that their wellbeing is top of mind, while actually enforcing a safety culture.

The second session we attended was “Driver Safety: Lucky vs. Good” where we learned that the highest auto expenses result from rear end accidents. Also, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ national census of fatal injuries released in December of 2021, transportation incidents have the most workplace fatalities, followed by falls and struck by objects. We also learned with new vehicle technology, such as high-intensity headlights, forward automatic braking, forward collision alert, lane departure warning and rear vision cameras, employers can help reduce vehicle crashes. The speaker went on to explain the importance of utilizing the data given by fleet analytics to help with reducing collision and use as a tool for focusing on trends happening within your fleet.

The final keynote speaker was Sean Bott and he spoke on the “Safety Dance: Creating the Courage to Connect on Site through Three Simple Steps.” His session was not only comedic, but also entertaining. He was able to teach us the 3 steps of meaningful connection; 1) Interrupting, 2) Introducing and 3) Inquiring. We have to start by interrupting people’s defenses and fears and can do this simply by a genuine compliment, a smile, a wave, etc. Then, once the walls are down, we are able to introduce ourselves while slowly saying our name with a pause between our first and last name, all while using the triple nod technique. He also encouraged us to smile and even throw in a wave during this process of introduction. Finally, we were taught to inquire in a clear and meaningful way to get to know the other person on a deeper level. He related these skills back to how employers interact with their employees on all levels, but specifically when it comes to safety. He suggested that we all combine these three skills to make others feel seen, heard, felt and valued. He displayed the value in bringing the human element to safety and reminding the group that the ultimate goal is to make sure all employees go home safely.  

Overall, this workshop was very informative with some fun mixed in and ample time for networking to get to know the other companies involved in the Captive. As a Rancho Mesa broker attending with several of our clients, it allowed us to see the value of not only this workshop, but the additional benefits of being a member of the Artisans Captive and what it offers.

For those interested in learning more about Captives and their potential place within your organization, we will be hosting an informational Captive workshop for the Artisans Captive on April the 28th. Register online, today.

If you have any questions or would like to discuss this option further, you can contact me at awebb@ranchomesa.com or call me at (619) 486-6562.

Read More

Hydraulics Safety in the Tree Care Industry

Author, Rory Anderson, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Tree care professionals regularly work with equipment that utilizes hydraulics: aerial lifts, stump grinders, and chippers, just to name a few. Injuries from hydraulic fluid leaks are very serious and can result in amputation.

Author, Rory Anderson, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Tree care professionals regularly work with equipment that utilizes hydraulics: aerial lifts, stump grinders, and chippers, just to name a few.

Injuries from hydraulic fluid leaks are very serious and can result in amputation. These injuries occur when hydraulic fluid is lost through a small hole and comes in contact with the skin of a worker. The injury can at first look like a mild, small puncture wound – but the truth is that they are anything but minor.

Hydraulic fluids are toxic and act as a poison to the body. In almost all cases, treatment (surgery) is immediately required to save the workers limb.

Stump grinders, chippers, and other equipment that tree care professionals use commonly run at 4,000 PSI, and the pressure needed to penetrate your skin is only 100 PSI.  So, it is vital that employees be trained on how to safely use hydraulic equipment.

Hydraulics safety trainings should include:

  • an overview and description of which equipment utilizes hydraulics;

  • proper techniques to check for leaks;

  • how to handle leaks;

  • how to handle injuries;

  • regular maintenance and upkeep on hydraulic hoses; and

  • the appropriate time to replace hydraulic hoses.

Make sure hydraulics safety is on your list of rotating topics that are regularly discussed with your crews at safety meetings.

For assistance with building your library of safety material for tailgate topics, reach out to me directly at (619) 486-6437 or randerson@ranchomesa.com.

Read More
Risk Management, News, OSHA, Construction Guest User Risk Management, News, OSHA, Construction Guest User

SB 606 Broadens Cal/OSHA’s Enforcement Reach

Author, Sam Brown, Vice President, Human Services Group, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

California Governor Gavin Newsom recently signed into law Senate Bill 606 (SB 606), greatly expanding Cal/OSHA’s enforcement powers and monetary penalty amounts. The new law will take effect January 1, 2022, so California employers have only a few months to tighten their safety practices or face steep monetary fines.

Author, Sam Brown, Vice President, Human Services Group, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

California Governor Gavin Newsom recently signed into law Senate Bill 606 (SB 606), greatly expanding Cal/OSHA’s enforcement powers and monetary penalty amounts. The new law will take effect January 1, 2022, so California employers have only a few months to tighten their safety practices or face steep monetary fines.

The new law could be especially damaging to employers with multiple worksites. SB 606 creates a rebuttable presumption that an employer with multiple worksites has committed an “enterprise-wide” violation, if Cal/OSHA determines either of the following is true:

  • The employer has a non-compliant written policy or procedure.

  • Cal/OSHA "has evidence of a pattern or practice of the same violation or violations committed by that employer involving more than one of the employer's worksites."

This change creates the possibility that a California employer adhering to a written program applicable to all locations can be cited for each California worksite.

Cal/OSHA will also have the authority to seek a temporary restraining order and an injunction against any employer suspected to have committed an enterprise-wide violation.

The far-reaching second part of the law states that if Cal/OSHA determines an employer has “willfully and egregiously” committed a violation, the employer may receive a citation “for each egregious violation” and “each instance of any employee exposed to that violation shall be considered a separate violation for purposes of the issuance of fines and penalties.”

The law details seven bases for “egregious” conduct. Proof of only one will be sufficient to justify a citation.

California employers must prioritize a full review of safety policies, procedures, and practices to reduce the likelihood of an “enterprise-wide” or “egregious” conduct violation. Cal/OSHA’s Consultation Branch offers free on-site visits to proactively address any potential violations.

 For helpful safety resources and compliance information, please contact me at (619) 937-0175 or sbrown@ranchomesa.com.

Read More
News, Risk Management Guest User News, Risk Management Guest User

Mitigate Janitorial Industry’s Employee Theft Exposure

Author, Jeremy Hoolihan, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Employee theft can be detrimental to any business and can come in many forms. Janitorial businesses, in particular, have an inherent risk of employee theft as employees often work alone at the client’s property with little to no supervision and access to valuables. Employee theft can start with smaller items that are easily overlooked and can quickly escalate. These types of losses are not only a financial burden, but can also tarnish the business’ reputation.

Author, Jeremy Hoolihan, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Image of janitors cleaning office desks.

Employee theft can be detrimental to any business and can come in many forms. Janitorial businesses, in particular, have an inherent risk of employee theft as employees often work alone at the client’s property with little to no supervision and access to valuables. Employee theft can start with smaller items that are easily overlooked and can quickly escalate. These types of losses are not only a financial burden, but can also tarnish the business’ reputation.

Insurance companies typically break employee theft into two categories: 1st party and 3rd party theft or crime. When an employee steals directly from the employer, it is called 1st party crime. Examples of this include embezzlement, inventory theft, theft of supplies, and more. Third party crime occurs when an employee steals property from the employer’s client or vendor. Examples of this would include stealing property from a client’s premises such as laptops, cash, etc. 

It is important to note that most insurance policies do not automatically cover employee theft. Those that extend coverage typically only offer 1st party crime via an endorsement and provide lower limits than stand-alone policies.

Janitorial companies can protect themselves from theft exposure by securing a fidelity bond or business services bond, a commercial crime policy, or through obtaining a specialty enhancement endorsement which adds 1st and 3rd party crime coverage to a package policy.

A fidelity bond protects a company if employees commit theft, fraud, or other dishonest acts. Most insurance policies exclude dishonest and malicious acts which includes employee theft.

A commercial crime policy and fidelity bond are similar in some respects, but they differ in that commercial crime insurance covers a wider range of threats, while fidelity bonds offer more targeted coverage. In addition to the offerings listed above, a commercial crime policy could cover crimes by people outside of the company, including burglary, theft, and forgery.

As mentioned, a third option is purchasing a 1st and 3rd party crime enhancement endorsement to the package policy. This is typically the most cost effective; however, these endorsements are usually only available through specialty programs specific to niche industries like janitorial and typically have limited access. Rancho Mesa’s MaintenanceOne™ Janitorial Program has access to markets that provide these specific endorsements.

To discuss these options in further detail, please reach out to me at 619-937-0174 or at jhoolihan@ranchomesa.com.

Read More

Experience Mod KPI Provides Trend Analysis, Opportunity Assessment, and Vital Management Tools

Author, Drew Garcia, Vice President, Landscape Group, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

In January 2021, we launched the Safety Key Performance Indicator (KPI) Dashboard to provide a tool for our customers to use as a bridge between their experience mod and safety performance.

Author, Drew Garcia, Vice President, Landscape Group, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Image of arborists looking at trees.

In January 2021, we launched the Safety Key Performance Indicator (KPI) Dashboard to provide a tool for our customers to use as a bridge between their experience mod and safety performance.

Our primary goals were to:

  • Eliminate surprises

  • Simplify concepts

  • Track performance

  • Highlight the positive and negative trends

  • Benchmark safety performance against industry competitors

An experience mod above 100 can limit a landscape company’s ability to be awarded jobs or maintain contracts, increase insurance premiums, and have other significant financial implications.

Our dashboard is a tool companies can use to strategically manage the underlying components that directly impact the experience mod and help project future experience mod deviations.  Rancho Mesa can help interpret the results and provide insights to help improve your performance.

Not a Rancho Mesa client but interested in seeing what your dashboard looks like? Complete our new KPI Dashboard quick form, to see how your company measures up.

Read More

Top Three Professional Liability Exposures for Tree Care Companies

Author, Rory Anderson, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Professional tree care companies must have a general liability policy that will cover incidents that cause bodily injury or property damage resulting from their operations. However, there are situations that will not be covered under a typical general liability policy and would require professional liability coverage, or, in the tree care industry it would specifically be Arborist Errors and Omissions coverage. Here are three exposures that tree care companies face that a professional liability policy would address.

Author, Rory Anderson, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Image of arborists looking at trees.

Professional tree care companies must have a general liability policy that will cover incidents that cause bodily injury or property damage resulting from their operations. However, there are situations that will not be covered under a typical general liability policy and would require professional liability coverage, or, in the tree care industry it would specifically be Arborist Errors and Omissions coverage. Here are three exposures that tree care companies face that a professional liability policy would address.

Tree Work

At times, tree care companies could inadvertently remove the wrong tree or prune a tree incorrectly causing various issues. As a result, the client may bring action against the tree care company for a number of reasons, including:

  • The loss of the intrinsic value the tree provided – shade, design, look, etc.;

  • The dollar value of the tree for replacement;

  • Mental distress suffered by the client.

Adjacent Trees

A professional tree care company can also be held responsible for damage caused by a failed tree that they did not even touch, but was on or nearby a recent jobsite. To be held liable for a failed tree (when a tree experiences structural collapse or breakage of any part of the tree: trunk, roots, or limbs) that they did not perform work on may seem unfair, but the client may claim that the arborist is the specialist and has a responsibility to point out any trees on a jobsite that could be dangerous.

Professional Tree Advice (Consulting)

Most tree care companies have a certified arborist who offers tree consulting and will give a professional opinion on whether or not a tree is safe.  This leaves the tree care company potentially responsible in the event a tree that was deemed safe actually fails and causes property damage, or even worse, bodily injury to a human.

Tree work, adjacent trees and consulting are three common exposures not typically covered by a general liability policy; therefore, professional tree care companies must strongly consider some form of professional liability coverage. Work with your trusted insurance advisor and have them thoroughly assess your exposure to these concerns.  To learn more about professional liability coverage for the tree care industry, listen to our StudioOne™ Safety and Risk Management Podcast Episode 99.

Contact me for a complete risk analysis of your operations at randerson@ranchomesa.com or (619) 486-6437.

Read More

Implementing an Effective Fall Safety Program Can Have Serious Impacts

Author, Casey Craig, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Year after year, falls are among the leading type of workers’ compensation claims and generate the highest claim costs. They account for multiple infractions on the top 10 most frequently cited standards, according to the Occupational Safety and Health Administration. How can you, as a business owner, control your exposure and keep your employees productive and healthy?

Author, Casey Craig, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Overlay image of back of person in hard hat and fall protection harness with buildings in background.

Year after year, falls are among the leading type of workers’ compensation claims and generate the highest claim costs. They account for multiple infractions on the top 10 most frequently cited standards, according to the Occupational Safety and Health Administration. How can you, as a business owner, control your exposure and keep your employees productive and healthy?

Prevention

According to the Centers for Disease Control, “27% of the 900,380 nonfatal work injuries resulting in days away from work in 2018 were related to slips, trips, and falls.” That’s a shockingly large number especially when 100% of falls are preventable if you take the time to plan, according to the National Safety Council (NSC). The NSC recommends:

  • Walking a job before employees get there to ensure proper set up is achievable with the equipment you are bringing for that job.

  • Pay attention to environmental conditions such as wind, rain, or excessive heat.

  • Check your equipment frequently to ensure nothing is worn down or damaged.

  • Make sure employees are wearing the proper foot wear and other Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) items required for the individual job needs.

Having employees working on ladders or scaffolding is essential for some jobs, and fortunately is a risk you can control. In addition to evaluating the work site, the equipment, the environmental factors, and PPE needed, you should also evaluate the health and fitness of all employees. Factors to consider should include the employee’s:

  • Experience

  • Fitness level

  • Age

Height Matters

A fatal fall can happen at almost any height. According to the NSC, only 16% of fatal falls in 2016 occurred as a result of a fall from over 30 feet; however, 53% of fatal falls that year resulted from below 20 feet. Given this data, best practices would dictate that construction companies should step back and reevaluate the safety procedures they have in place and determine if any changes need to be made, particularly for jobs that are considered the lower heights.

RM365 Advantage Safety Star™ Program

To get your employees properly trained, we recommend enrolling in our RM365 Advantage Safety Star™ program that includes Fall Prevention training. This program includes fundamental safety topics that allows your foreman or key management team to go through internet-based safety trainings and earn their Safety Star certification. This program has shown to improve safety while helping to reduce your workers’ compensation premiums. Register to start your RM365 Advantage Safety Star™ program, today.

Rancho Mesa understands the exposure our clients face on a daily basis and can help implement safety procedures to mitigate these risks. Underestimating a project’s risk or undertraining employees is an exposure you can address.

If you would like help in reviewing your safety protocols and procedures or if you have further questions, do not hesitate to reach out to me at (619) 438-6900 or email me at ccraig@ranchomesa.com.

Read More

The Construction Risk Management Guide

Author, Daniel Frazee, Executive Vice President, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

As a business or firm, you are most likely aware of many risks that come with construction projects. Whether it is meeting the terms of a contract, maintaining employee safety on the job site, or dealing with natural disasters, every project has its own set of hazards. If not managed, these risks can compromise your projects and prove fatal to your bottom line.

Author, Daniel Frazee, Executive Vice President, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Image of words and tablets, papers, and laptops on wood desk.

As a business or firm, you are most likely aware of many risks that come with construction projects. Whether it is meeting the terms of a contract, maintaining employee safety on the job site, or dealing with natural disasters, every project has its own set of hazards. If not managed, these risks can compromise your projects and prove fatal to your bottom line. Thus, construction risk management is a must-have for any company, but an effective plan must have easy-to-follow, yet detailed processes to help you control the risks, make decisions on how to deal with them, and turn them around to uplift your company. With the presence of rising material costs, more complex projects and increased safety concerns, having a risk management plan is more crucial than ever.

What is Construction Risk Management?

Risk management is the process of determining the risks present in your business and evaluating the procedures to minimize their impact. In the construction world, the process involves planning, monitoring and controlling instances of risk. At the center of this process is your risk management plan, a formal document that details the risks and your processes for addressing them.

Sources of construction risks may include:

  • Safety Risk - any risks or hazards that can lead to worker accidents at a construction site;

  • Financial Risk - internal and external factors like sales, problems with the economy, unexpected cost increases and competition from other firms;

  • Legal Risk - disputes in the fulfillment of contracts with clients;

  • Project Risk - hazards such as poor management of resources, miscalculation of time, lack of proper policies, etc.; and

  • Environmental Risk - natural phenomena that damage construction sites like floods and earthquakes.

How to Manage Risks

Before you can manage risk, companies must develop a risk management plan. This process can be broken down into six steps.

  1. Identify the Risks
    Risk identification should take place during the preconstruction phase of a project to allow ample time to manage any potential risks before accepting them. One effective way is to hold brainstorming sessions with your project team with an emphasis on identifying all the possible scenarios that could impact the project at hand. Once the brainstorm is complete, hold regular meetings to continually identify new risks that develop.

  2. Prioritize Risks in Order of Importance
    High-probability risks should be handled first while low-impact, low probability risks should be addressed last. As an example, an unexpected price increase in the materials for your project can severely hurt your profit margins and might be considered a high priority.

  3. Determine your Response Strategy
    Once you have evaluated the priority of risks, your team must decide a response strategy for each hazard. You can avoid the risk altogether, mitigate the risk, transfer the risk if possible via insurance and/or performance bonds, or accept the risk.

  4. Execute the Plan
    Much like a sports team on game day, your company now has to execute the plan after you have developed your strategy. Your plan must detail crucial information for each team member and provide specific solutions to mitigate, transfer, or accept risks.

  5. Involve Members of the Team
    Great plans are developed with multiple opinions, involving contribution from all team members typically including the ownership group, the financial officers, and the field team. Members are managing cash flows, schedules, inspections, project logs, contracts and regulatory documents.

  6. Create Contingencies and Revise
    Strong risk management programs have contingency plans. That is, alternative methods for finishing a project despite accepting the risk. Consistent monitoring and revisions to your plan will help increase resilience against any possible risk and ensure that your “document” evolves and changes over time.

Benefits of Risk Management in Construction

Along with the actual building process, risk management should be seen as one of the most critical steps of a construction project. Identifying, assessing, controlling and monitoring risks strengthen awareness and teamwork among those key members of your organization. Working in step with your insurance broker for resources, templates, and feedback can be key to integrating your plan with the company’s safety initiatives. Request a sample Accident Prevention Template to start your Construction Risk Management plan. And, in turn, communicating an effective and tested plan to the insurance marketplace can position you and your broker to leverage the most competitive terms and pricing within your renewal cycle.

For more information or questions related to this article, please contact me at 619-937-0172 or via email dfrazee@ranchomesa.com.

Read More

Can Employers Mandate a COVID-19 Vaccination Policy?

Author, Sam Brown, Vice President of the Human Services Group, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

As COVID-19 vaccinations become more available and the positive results of our efforts are realized, employers may ask how this impacts the workforce and a full-scale return to the workplace. More specifically, they may ask if an employer can mandate a COVID-19 vaccination policy.

Author, Sam Brown, Vice President of the Human Services Group, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Image of money, calculator, piggy bank, magnifying glass, and financial document on desk.

As COVID-19 vaccinations become more available and the positive results of our efforts are realized, employers may ask how this impacts the workforce and a full-scale return to the workplace. More specifically, they may ask if an employer can mandate a COVID-19 vaccination policy.

The laws are complex, so please do not rely on this article as legal advice. Please consult your labor law attorney before deciding how to proceed.

The short answer is yes, employers can mandate a COVID-19 vaccination for employees, when it makes sense. 

The 1905 court case Jacobson v. Massachusetts forms the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission’s (EEOC) basis for guidance. Following a deadly smallpox outbreak in New England in 1901, the Supreme Court ruled that the government may impose “reasonable regulations” to protect the “safety of the general public.” The EEOC makes clear that employers may implement similar demands.

According to the EEOC, an employer can implement a mandatory vaccination policy if there is a job-related need for it or if non-vaccination threatens the health of other employees, customers or themselves. The EEOC’s guidelines date back to the 2009 outbreak of H1N1, and was updated in March 2020.

A mandatory COVID-19 vaccination policy would commonly be used in a health care environment or in emergency services where the likelihood of exposure may be higher based on the nature of the work, opposed to the average office environment that is following the Centers for Disease Control COVID-19 guidelines along with implementing a COVID-19 Prevention Plan.

Employers should take caution when deciding whether or not to implement such a policy and whether it makes sense for their industry and organization. According to OSHA’s January 2021 Guidance on Mitigating and Preventing the Spread of COVID-19 in the Workplace, employers should not distinguish between workers who are vaccinated and those who are not. All employee should follow the same safety precautions regardless of vaccination status. 

Essential workers in sectors like construction and landscaping, community-based organizations and financial services to name few, can operate under the provided guidance without requiring their employees to get the COVID-19 vaccine in order to resume normal business operations.

Some employers are waiting to impose a mandatory vaccination policy, choosing instead to offer employees incentives for getting vaccinated. These incentives may include a vacation day, a few hours of regular pay, or a cash bonus. To avoid discrimination, an employer may offer the incentive to all employees if the company’s work force meets a vaccination goal. Whatever path you decide, make sure to include the policy in your employee handbook or COVID-19 Prevention Plan.

Considering a recent Kaiser Family Foundation survey, 27% of Americans are “vaccine hesitant.” So, the employer will need to decide if a COVID-19 vaccination policy is right for their organization.  Questions regarding mandatory vaccinations will continue to present a challenge to employers.

For specific questions about your company’s vaccine policy, consult our RM365 HRAdvantage™ portal’s live HR experts.

Read More

The Heart of Rancho Mesa

Author, Daniel Frazee, Executive Vice President, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

If you are reading this article, listening to our podcasts, and taking advantage of the meaningful risk management content we share weekly, you and your business likely find some degree of value in what is produced. While much of this content originates from our Media Communications Group, they, with other Rancho Mesa family members join together as the backbone of our operation.

Author, Daniel Frazee, Executive Vice President, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Image of money, calculator, piggy bank, magnifying glass, and financial document on desk.

If you are reading this article, listening to our podcasts, and taking advantage of the meaningful risk management content we share weekly, you and your business likely find some degree of value in what is produced. While much of this content originates from our Media Communications Group, they, with other Rancho Mesa family members join together as the backbone of our operation. Our Certicians®, Account Coordinators, Benefit Analysts, Claim Advocates, Associate and Account Managers, and Sales Executives are the beating heart of our company. That core focuses on three main principles that guide our values, shape our decisions, and directly influence our daily interaction with clients and one another. They include Developing Solutions, Protecting Clients, and Building Trust.

Developing Solutions

A solution is defined as the act, method or process of solving a problem. Our clients face daily challenges and problems as they manage their organizations and continually look for competitive advantages. They rely on us to provide complete solutions but those can look far different across our many departments. Here are a few examples:

  • One of our Sales Executives might recommend higher limits of coverage or adjusting deductibles to meet new exposures.

  • Our Workers’ Compensation Claim Advocate might deliver a quarterly status to a company’s Safety Committee and make recommendations on return-to-work options. 

  • It might also include an Account Manager reviewing contractual requirements for a client bidding a new job.

  • And lastly, an Account Manager in our Benefits department might help to resolve a sensitive claim issue with a member. 

  • These actions are just a few of the many day-to-day priorities that are centered entirely on serving our customers. We remain fearless in our approach to problem solving!

Protecting Clients

Risk comes in all shapes and sizes. Protecting our clients with insurance is one vehicle we may use to transfer some or all of that risk to a third-party. But, that process can only be effective when our team actively listens to clients and prospective clients through regular interaction at policy audits, pre-renewal meetings, claim reviews, stewardship reports, and renewal meetings. 

A key part of that protection are the resources we offer internally that help mitigate risk and reduce overall exposure to claims across all lines of coverage. Those resources include our:

Our clients can use these tools for risk management trainings, HR issues and concerns, safety certifications, and consistent risk management education and guidance.

These examples represent a very small sample of what is available from our organization. Building a risk management program that centers on controlling losses by implementing the proper protocols and best practice techniques is ultimately our vision for protecting clients.

Building Trust

We cannot develop solutions and properly protect our clients without building customer relationships based on a deep level of mutual trust. And, we view a distinct difference between establishing trust and maintaining it over the course of our partnership. While we are proud that our customer retention ranks in the top percentile across the nation, we recognize that trust is the key component to our success. And so, our work is never done. We continually expect more from ourselves, our team members, and our carrier partners to maintain, and ultimately, exceed customer expectations. It is simply how we were built and what we stand for. We see No Limit to what we can do.

To learn more about Rancho Mesa Insurance, subscribe to our weekly newsletter and podcast.

Read More

Four Factors that Shape your Risk Profile

Author, Drew Garcia, Vice President, Landscape Group, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

How do you differentiate your company from your local competitors? Product, customer service, delivery, etc. The same can be said for your risk profile and insurance costs. Why are my insurance rates high when my competitors are low? This article breaks down four factors that influence your risk profile and impact pricing.

Author, Drew Garcia, Vice President, Landscape Group, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Image of risk and money bag on weighted scale.

How do you differentiate your company from your local competitors? Product, customer service, delivery, etc. The same can be said for your risk profile and insurance costs. Why are my insurance rates high when my competitors are low? Here are four factors that influence your risk profile and impact pricing:      

FREQUENCY OF CLAIMS

The frequency is the number of workers’ compensation claims you average.

Calculation – # of claims / basis

Evaluate – How often are you having workers’ compensation claims and how does that compare to other landscape companies in your region or state?  If frequency is high, a line can be drawn to conclude that your high frequency will lead to more lost time or severe injuries.

Action – If you are having a frequency issue, you need to assess:

  • Injury Type (back, hand, wrist, knee…)

  • Root Cause (lifting, punctures, slips…)

  • Implement corrective actions to help mitigate the risks associated with your claims. 

    Take it to the next level and evaluate “near misses.”  Treat a “near miss” as if it were a claim and strategize a corrective action to prevent it from happening in the future. 

Use our Risk Management Center to assign a training to the foremen or supervisor and injured employee to help prevent this from occurring in the future.

Indemnity (Lost Time) Claims

Indemnity is the number of  lost time claims your company experiences.

Calculation – # of lost time claims / basis

Evaluate – How often are you having indemnity claims that result in lost time and how does that compare to other landscape companies in your region or State? 

Action – If you are having an Indemnity issue, you need to assess:

  • Injury Type (back, hand, wrist, knee…)

  • Root Cause (lifting, punctures, slips…)

  • Implement corrective actions to help mitigate the risks associated with your claims. 

    Establish a “return-to-work” program which allows your injured employees an opportunity to come back to work on limited duty. 

    Improve accident investigation, documentation, and claim reporting protocols to equal best practices.

Experience Rating

Your experience rating is a combination of your loss data and total payroll when compared to your industry typically over a three year period.  Your experience rating will either credit or debit your workers’ compensation premium accordingly.

Calculation – Project your Experience Modification (XMOD) 6 months early at your Unit Stat filing.

Evaluate – Determine the impact changes in your Expected Loss Rate (ELR) and Primary Threshold will have on your next XMOD.

Action – Controlling your frequency of claims and number of indemnity claims will lower your Experience Modification. 

Operations

Heavier operations would include hardscape construction, tree trimming, and snow removal in which generally heavier machinery and product is used, thus a higher exposure to injury.  Compare these types of landscape operations to a lighter exposure such as landscape maintenance, mowing, edging and pruning. 

Calculation – Determine the percentages of your operations that fall into the various landscape work areas.

Evaluate – Identify the exposures that are unique to each area of your operations.

Action – Implement safety programs catered to your exposures that will mitigate risk and help protect your employees.  Although your operations might be heavier, you have the ability to implement tactics to reduce or prevent the claims from happening, thereby subjectively and objectively making your risk profile more appealing. 

We have seen 100% landscape construction firms achieve industry low experience XMODs and the markets most aggressive rates.   Don’t wait for the injury to occur; be proactive and stop the claim before it transpires. 

Your risk profile has already been created whether you know it or not.  The opportunity for you to own it and improve it is always available.

With one click of the mouse, you can see how you stack up against your competitors through our Key Performance Indicator (KPI) dashboard, today.

Contact me to get a customized KPI dashboard at (619) 937-0200 or drewgarcia@ranchomesa.com.

Read More

Total Cost of Risk

Author, Rory Anderson, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

The total cost of risk is the sum of the measurable expenses that are associated with managing risk within any organization. Every successful business has a process for tracking and measuring performance to improve results. It is important for business owners to keep a pulse on key performance indicators. But, how are you measuring risk related costs? Some people may think that insurance premiums are the only cost associated with risk, but we need to look at the bigger picture.

 Author, Rory Anderson, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Image of risk and money bag on weighted scale.

The total cost of risk is the sum of the measurable expenses that are associated with managing risk within any organization. Every successful business has a process for tracking and measuring performance to improve results. It is important for business owners to keep a pulse on key performance indicators. But, how are you measuring risk related costs? Some people may think that insurance premiums are the only cost associated with risk, but we need to look at the bigger picture.

In fact, insurance premiums only make up one fifth of an organizations total cost of risk. If you are only considering insurance premiums as a way of quantifying your company’s risk related costs, you are missing costs that you have control over. All risk-related costs can be observed and monitored. Also, there are certain strategies that, once implemented, will reduce those costs if executed correctly. That’s what total cost of risk is all about. There are five components that make up an organization’s total cost of risk: insurance premiums, retained losses, internal risk management costs, outside vendor fees, and indirect claim costs.

Insurance Premiums

An insurance premium is the payment that a company agrees to pay in order to have insurance. It is the most obvious component that makes up the total cost of risk and represents an important piece of the puzzle.

Retained Losses

There are two types of retained losses, active and passive. An active loss is simply when you have a deductible. If you have a deductible, you made a decision on the front end to take on (or retain) some of the risk, and pay a specified out of pocket amount for situations involving claims. On the other hand, a passive loss is any loss that is unexpected and not accounted for anywhere else. It could be a loss that is not covered by insurance and therefore must be covered out of pocket by the organization. Retained losses, active or passive, must be included when factoring total cost of risk.

Internal Risk Management Costs

Consider internal risk management costs as well. Maybe you have a full-time safety director. What is their salary? What about the person who is responsible for keeping track of the workers’ compensation claims, or the HR person who is in charge of managing and updating the employee handbook every time a new state law is passed? Calculate the internal hours that are spent looking at safety and risk management, and assign a dollar amount. These are costs that typically can be overlooked.

Outside Vendor Fees

You cannot forget to allocate any potential outsourced costs into the total cost of risk. Maybe you hired an outside firm to complete anti-harassment or First Aid/CPR training for your employees. Did you bring in outside safety consultants? These costs add up and need to be considered, as well.

Indirect Claim Costs

The last factor that makes up the total cost of risk are indirect costs associated with claims. These are secondary costs that are linked to claims. For example, with workers’ compensation insurance, the direct costs such as medical costs, indemnity payments, and legal services are just the tip of the iceberg. Some examples of indirect costs that are not covered by insurance are OSHA fines, accident investigation, implementation of corrective measures, hiring replacement workers, loss of productivity, etc.

Total cost of risk is critical for organizations to understand for several reasons. First, it helps you make educated and informed risk management decisions. You may want to invest into new equipment or bring in additional safety training from the outside. If you don’t know the total cost of risk and the ultimate impact in terms of upfront expense and projected return, how can you make the best decision?

Understanding your organization’s total cost of risk also helps you benchmark your progress towards your financial goals and objectives. It’s a quantifiable, controllable number that can be identified and reduced. It’s a metric that must be used to evaluate the overall success of your risk management process. When an organization is looking at their total cost of risk, they are focusing on the entire risk management function, which ultimately can lead to stronger safety programs and a reduction in frequency and severity of claims.

For questions about how your company can account for its total cost of risk, contact me at (619) 486-6437 or randerson@ranchomesa.com.

Read More

4 Key Factors in Developing a Motor Vehicle Report Program

Author, Jeremy Hoolihan, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Auto liability is often one of the most substantial risks a business will have. Driver selection is one of the most important evaluations a business can do to prevent accidents. It’s been proven that drivers with a history of moving violations and accidents pose a higher risk for organizations. Best practices for reducing this risk allow only safe drivers to operate a company vehicle.

Author, Jeremy Hoolihan, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Image of driver wearing hard hat and yellow vest in van.

Auto liability is often one of the most substantial risks a business will have. Driver selection is one of the most important evaluations a business can do to prevent accidents. It’s been proven that drivers with a history of moving violations and accidents pose a higher risk for organizations. Best practices for reducing this risk allow only safe drivers to operate a company vehicle. In order to manage this process, a business should develop a Motor Vehicle Records (MVR) Program as part of their Fleet Safety Program to ensure safe employees are driving company vehicles. There are four key factors in developing an MVR Program

  1. Obtaining the MVR.

  2. Evaluating the MVR.

  3. Applying the MVR.

  4. Documenting the MVR.

Obtaining the MVR

Obtaining the MVR is the first step of determining whether a driver meets acceptability standards. Best practices recommend that all employees who drive on company time, whether that is driving a company vehicle or their own, should have their MVR requested and evaluated at least on an annual basis. Some companies choose to obtain the MVR of those employees who drive regularly and not those that drive on an incidental basis. It’s best to consult your attorney but many believe at least verification that a license is valid should be established for incidental drivers.

Evaluating the MVR

Now, the employer has obtained the MVR and it needs to be evaluated. Many insurance companies evaluate a MVR based on three criteria:

  1. The age of the driver. The minimum age for a driver varies by insurance company. Generally speaking, the minimum age to be eligible to drive on a commercial auto policy is 21-23 years old. It is strongly recommended that your MVR Program adheres to a minimum age requirement because there is a much higher percentage of accidents by young inexperienced drivers.

  2. The length of time driver has maintained a valid license. Driver experience is another factor that should be strongly considered while evaluating a MVR. Most insurance companies are looking for at least three years of driving experience. With younger generations obtaining their licenses later and later, you may run into issues of drivers not meeting the minimum experience requirement. There may also be drivers that have been licensed in other states, which would show little experience in the state where they are now licensed. It may be necessary to verify a driver’s previous license status in another state.

  3. The number of violations and infractions the driver has on their license. This could be the single most important factor in establishing driver eligibility. Drivers who have a history of moving violations and accidents pose a higher risk to an organization. When evaluating a MVR report, it’s important to establish consistent requirements that are agreed upon by the organization and insurance company. A common acceptable MVR includes:

a. No more than two minor moving violations and one preventable accident in a three-year period. A minor moving violation includes speeding (i.e., 1-14 mph over posted limit), improper lane change, failure to yield, failure to obey traffic signal or sign, and an accident.

b. No more than two zero-point infractions such as cell phone ticket, seat belt ticket, and texting in the last three years.

c. No major violations in the past five years such as a DUI, leaving the scene of an accident, excessive speeds over 20 mph over limit, reckless driving, felony involving the use of a vehicle, and license suspension or revocation resulting from accidents or moving violations.

Applying the MVR     

Once the MVR has been evaluated, it’s time to determine which drivers are eligible and which are not. This can certainly pose a problem when implementing a new MVR Program with existing employees and drivers. A company may have to evaluate whether an employee’s driving responsibilities are suspended, if they need to be re-assigned to a non-driving position, or in certain circumstances might have to be terminated (such as a delivery driver). It’s also possible to consider a transitional period for those that are now considered ineligible. It is also important to consult the HR Department and company attorney when making these transitions.

Documenting the MVR

Proper documentation of a company’s MVR process should be consistent and contained in each employee’s file. The employee’s file should have any applications, the MVR, warnings or corrective actions taken, annual MVR reports, and any signed release forms.

A formal MVR Program is a vital piece to a successful Fleet Safety Program. It creates a barrier of minimum requirements that can often weed out potential unsafe drivers and future liability. If you need assistance in developing a Fleet Safety and MVR Program, please feel free to reach out to me at (619) 937-0174 or jhoolhan@ranchomesa.com

Read More

Safety Programs Can Reduce Workers’ Compensation Premiums

Author, Daniel Frazee, Executive Vice President, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

As California business owners continue incurring costs as they work their way through the maze of ever-changing COVID-19 regulations and protocols, prioritizing critical elements of your internal safety program can directly lower your insurance costs. Refocusing on key areas below will help present an effective, detailed submission to the marketplace that will lead to talking points with an underwriter for schedule credits and ultimately, lower rates and premiums.

Author, Daniel Frazee, Executive Vice President, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

Image of man in suit writing on screen. Showing down arrow titles “workers’ compensation premiums”

As California business owners continue incurring costs as they work their way through the maze of ever-changing COVID-19 regulations and protocols, prioritizing critical elements of your internal safety program can directly lower your insurance costs. Refocusing on key areas below will help present an effective, detailed submission to the marketplace that will lead to talking points with an underwriter for schedule credits and ultimately, lower rates and premiums.

Employee Benefits

Workers’ compensation underwriters pay close attention to employee benefit plans from a submission they are reviewing to quote. A deeper dive will create inquiries on overall employee participation, employer’s contribution to the plan, and whether established “wellness” plans are made available. High participation and contribution can show underwriters that employees value the benefits being offered and that the employer is investing in their most important asset, the employees. Lastly, industry professionals commonly link reduced fraudulent workers’ compensation claims to more robust, supported employee benefit programs.

Formal Safety Program

Developing a formal, documented Injury and Illness Prevention Program (IIPP) is truly just a baseline for managing risk for any business. The IIPP must be a living, changing document that contemplates random/periodic inspections, regular meeting intervals, safety orientation for new employees, and detailed investigative reports performed by field and management. Your program can be compared to a book that sits on the shelf and develops dust. Or, if you are focused on best practice techniques, it can be used as a tool for education, training, and risk mitigation. It should change as your company changes and incorporate the safety priorities instilled from the top down. Additionally, incorporating safety programs like Rancho Mesa’s RM365 Advantage Safety Star™ training program for foreman and supervisors help make your safety program go to the next level and really stand out in the insurance marketplace. Dynamic IIPPs stand out in a workers’ compensation submission process. They provide much needed detail to simple Yes/No questions on a supplemental application and show just how important safety is to the organization that is being underwritten.

Return to Work Program

Companies of all types will share that they support a return to work program when their injured employee is cleared for modified duty. That support needs to be taken a few steps further to improve your program. Create job descriptions for potential modified positions. Identify and engage with specific doctors within your network and ensure that these job descriptions are on file. This process can often help expedite employees back to the field, warehouse, office, etc. and ultimately lower temporary disability payments which can lower claim reserves. Use Rancho Mesa’s RM365 HRAdvantage™ portal to generate job descriptions and manage employee’s modified duty in the Risk Management Center.

Hiring Practices

Developing “gates” in the hiring process are often overlooked as too expensive or time consuming.  But, the costs of bad hiring decisions can linger for years, impacting your bottom line and employee morale. Employers must strongly consider pre-employment physicals and drug testing, typically performed post interview and before an offer is made. As the Compliance Director for Current Consulting Group LLC, Andrew Current said, “The average cost of a pre-employment drug test is $45. The average turnover cost for an entry level employee is $6,600.”  There is added benefit with workers’ compensation underwriters who view pre-employment checks as key controls to minimizing claim frequency and severity. Take advantage of the New Employee Onboarding Checklist and other resources in the RM365 HRAdvantage Portal.

Website Development

Most, if not all, workers’ compensation underwriters begin their review process by accessing the company in question’s website to learn more about their operation, exposures, risks, etc. Therefore, seeing your website through this same filter and utilizing your broker as an additional soundboard of information, consider these possible edits and/or redesign of your website:

  • Add a “Safety” link or tab, allowing space for sharing your company’s philosophy on managing risk.

  • Include a section on any safety awards or recognition that you may have received.

  • Remove any pictures on your website that might create confusion or concern about your operation as it relates to safety and risk.

  • Include examples of safety protocol that are unique to your operation (e.g. proper use of machinery, ladder usage, cleanliness of operating areas, etc).

Like any potential internal investment, companies must always balance whether the time and resource commitment will ultimately benefit their company. Many of the above recommendations require minimal resources and can pay huge dividends in consistently securing the most competitive workers’ compensation pricing, often a significant line item on a profit and loss statement. You may find cost savings in areas you did not know were possible that can help your business survive and remain profitable in these difficult times.

To discuss how your company’s safety program can affect your workers’ compensation premium, contact me at (619) 937-0172 or dfrazee@ranchomesa.com.

Read More