WCIRB 2024 Construction Dual Wage Threshold Increases Approved

California Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara has approved an increase in hourly wage thresholds for all 16 construction dual-wage classifications.

The increases range from $1 to $4 depending on the classification and will go into effect for policyholders on their workers’ compensation policy renewal date on or after September 1, 2024. The chart below outlines the proposed increases for each classification.

Dual Wage Classifications	Existing Threshold	Proposed Increase	Proposed Threshold
5027/5028 Masonry	$32	$3	$35
5190/5140 Electrical Wiring	$34	$2	$36
5183/5187 Plumbing	$31	$1	$32
5185/5186 Automatic Sprinkler	$32	$1	$33
5201/5205 Concrete Work	$32	$1	$33
5403/5432 Carpentry	$39	$2	$41
5446/5447 Wallboard Installation	$38	$3	$41
5467/5470 Glaziers	$36	$3	$39
5474/5482 Painting Waterproofing	$31	$1	$32
5484/5485 Plastering or Stucco	$36	$2	$38
5538/5542 Sheet Metal Work	$29	$4	$33
5552/5553 Roofing	$29	$2	$31
5632/5633 Steel Framing	$39	$2	$41
6218/6220 Grading/Land Leveling	$38	$2	$40
6307/6308 Sewer Construction	$38	$2	$40
6315/6316 Water/Gas Mains	$38	$2	$40

In light of the ongoing labor shortage within the construction industry, employers have been making a concerted effort to retain their workforce. This includes providing more comprehensive benefits packages, including higher wages, and merit-based bonuses when appropriate. As a result, these new wage classification increases may prompt employers to consider extending further salary increases to their employees, with the aim of reducing workers' compensation premiums.

To better understand these changes and plan for the impact this will have on your company, please call us at 619-937-0164 and ask to speak to a member of our construction group.

WCIRB Proposes 2024 Construction Dual Wage Threshold Increase

The Workers' Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau (WCIRB) has proposed an increase in hourly wage thresholds for all 16 construction dual-wage classifications.

The increases range from $1 to $4 depending on the classification and if approved will go into effect for policyholders renewing September 1, 2024 and thereafter. The chart below outlines the proposed increases for each classification.

Dual Wage Classifications	Existing Threshold	Proposed Increase	Proposed Threshold
5027/5028 Masonry	$32	$3	$35
5190/5140 Electrical Wiring	$34	$2	$36
5183/5187 Plumbing	$31	$1	$32
5185/5186 Automatic Sprinkler	$32	$1	$33
5201/5205 Concrete Work	$32	$1	$33
5403/5432 Carpentry	$39	$2	$41
5446/5447 Wallboard Installation	$38	$3	$41
5467/5470 Glaziers	$36	$3	$39
5474/5482 Painting Waterproofing	$31	$1	$32
5484/5485 Plastering or Stucco	$36	$2	$38
5538/5542 Sheet Metal Work	$29	$4	$33
5552/5553 Roofing	$29	$2	$31
5632/5633 Steel Framing	$39	$2	$41
6218/6220 Grading/Land Leveling	$38	$2	$40
6307/6308 Sewer Construction	$38	$2	$40
6315/6316 Water/Gas Mains	$38	$2	$40

In light of the ongoing labor shortage within the construction industry, employers have been making a concerted effort to retain their workforce. This includes providing more comprehensive benefits packages, including higher wages, and offering merit-based bonuses when appropriate. As a result, these proposed wage classification increases may prompt employers to consider extending further salary increases to their employees, with the aim of reducing workers' compensation premiums.

Rancho Mesa predicts that this information will become a major factor in payroll decisions based on overhead cost management and recommend this as a topic for discussion early, so that our clients and prospects can prepare.

Roofing Contractors Prepare for the Dual Wage Threshold Increase

Author, Kevin Howard, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

There is a lot at stake for roofing contractors in California. Many of us recall playing the game “would you rather” as kids. Would you rather jump into a freezing cold pool in December or eat the world’s hottest chili pepper with no milk available?

For roofers across the state, the question for them is, “would you rather give strategic pay raises to key employees or pay higher than necessary worker’s compensation premiums?” The ideal solution would be to give appropriate pay raises to help retain quality employees and to pay less for worker’s compensation.

To get into the math, the Workers’ Compensation Rating Bureau (WCIRB) has increased the dual wage threshold for the roofing class codes 5552 and 5553 by $2. The prior wage threshold was $27 per hour. The change that went into effect September 1, 2022 adjusted the new wage threshold to $29 for these same codes.

So, any roofers renewing on or after September 1, 2022 will need to explore what makes the most sense regarding the hourly wages of their employees.

This increase for roofing contractors is critical to understand because of the massive rate difference between class code 5553 ($29 or more per hour) and (under $29 per hour).

To drill down further, we analyzed the base rates for class codes 5552 and 5553 from 10 different worker’s compensation carriers. The average delta in base rates was 65%. That is a huge swing in cost for any roofing contractor who is not familiar with the cost benefit analysis that must take place.

As an example, we will use $1 million in payroll for 3 different scenarios to help paint a picture of this wage threshold change.

SCENARIO #1:

ABC Roofing has $1 million in payroll and all employees make $27 per hour. Using a hypothetical net rate of $40 for class code 5552, the insurance premium for scenario #1 would be $400,000.

SCENARIO #2:

XYZ Roofing has $1 million in payroll and all employee make $29 per hour. Using a hypothetical net rate of $14 (which is 65% less than $40), the projected workers’ compensation annual estimated premium would be $140,000.

SCENARIO #3:

ABC’s insurance agent made them aware of the new wage threshold increase well in advance of their renewal. They gave appropriate wage increases to 75% of employees and now have $250,000 of payroll in class code 5552 and $750,000 in class code 5553. Using the same hypothetical net rates from scenarios #1 and #2, the worker’s compensation annual estimated premium would be $205,000.

In conclusion, the massive delta in base and net rates for the roofing class codes 5552 and 5553 requires a proactive approach with your broker in advance of your upcoming workers’ compensation renewal. Laying out options that can include strategic pay increases can and will ultimately bring significant premium savings to your roofing company. With inflationary costs across all trades trending upward, build a plan now to help offset these rising costs.

To learn more about this topic or have a conversation with us, please email me at khoward@ranchomesa.com or call (619) 438-6874.

WCIRB Approves 2022 Construction Dual Wage Threshold Increase

The Workers' Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau (WCIRB) has approved the recommended increase in hourly wage thresholds for all 16 construction dual wage classifications.

The increases range from $2 to $5 depending on the classification and will go into effect for policyholders renewing September 1, 2022 and thereafter. The chart below outlines the increases for each classification.

Dual Wage Classifications	Existing Threshold	Approved Increase	Approved Threshold
5027/5028 Masonry	$28	$4	$32
5190/5140 Electrical Wiring	$32	$2	$34
5183/5187 Plumbing	$28	$3	$31
5185/5186 Automatic Sprinkler	$29	$3	$32
5201/5205 Concrete Work	$28	$4	$32
5403/5432 Carpentry	$35	$4	$39
5446/5447 Wallboard Installation	$36	$2	$38
5467/5470 Glaziers	$33	$3	$36
5474/5482 Painting Waterproofing	$28	$3	$31
5484/5485 Plastering or Stucco	$32	$4	$36
5538/5542 Sheet Metal Work	$27	$2	$29
5552/5553 Roofing	$27	$2	$29
5632/5633 Steel Framing	$35	$4	$39
6218/6220 Grading/Land Leveling	$34	$5	$39
6307/6308 Sewer Construction	$34	$5	$39
6315/6316 Water/Gas Mains	$34	$5	$39

With the continuing labor shortage in construction, employers have been doing everything possible to retain employees by offering richer benefits plans, pay increases and merit bonuses, when applicable. These approved wage classification increases could potentially push employers to extend additional pay raises to employees in an effort to minimize workers’ compensation premiums.

Rancho Mesa predicts that this information will become a major factor in payroll decisions based on overhead cost management and recommend this as a topic for discussion early, so that our clients and prospects can prepare.

Understanding the Impact of MEP Contractors’ Dual Wage & Total Temporary Disability

Author, Sam Clayton, Vice President, Construction Group, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

What is a dual wage threshold? According to the Workers’ Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau (WCIRB), in California there are sixteen (16) construction operations that are divided into two separate classifications based on the hourly wage of the employee. There are different advisory pure premium rates for the low wage employee and the high wage employee. For mechanical, electrical and plumbing (MEP) contractors, the class codes used are all included in the recently approved increase which will go into effect September 1, 2022. The table below outlines the changes for the MEP class codes by year.

Classifications	9/1/2021 - Current	9/1/2022 - Proposed
5140/5190	$32	$34
5183/5187	$28	$31
5538/5542	$27	$29

© 2021 Workers' Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau of California. All Rights Reserved.

Why does this matter to MEP contractors? The higher wage employee’s workers’ compensation rate is significantly less (on average 46% less) than the lower wage employee. Therefore, if a company has any employees that are currently just barley in the high wage classification, this would drop those employees into the low wage classification and the employer would pay the higher workers’ compensation rate on those individuals. Depending on how many employees an employer has in this situation, it may be advantageous for the employer to calculate if it makes more sense to give those impacted employees a raise to push them back up into the high wage classification or keep them in the new low wage classification. It should be noted and understood that this change will not impact the employer until their next renewal after September 1, 2022. So while most employers will have time to evaluate the impact, it is crucial to begin the evaluation sooner rather than later.

As with any form of wage inflation, an increase in wages, to keep an employee in the higher wage category will increase the claim costs of a total temporary disability claim if they are injured on the job. While increases in wages are necessary, they will also impact the total cost of the claim, which then can increase the company’s experience modification rating (XMOD).

To mitigate this increase and reduce the likelihood of a lost time claim, employers can take several actions:

• Review and update their existing safety programs.

• Revisit their hiring practices.

• Develop a sustainable return-to-work program.

What should employers do next?

• Work with your trusted insurance advisor and run a needs/benefit analysis on increasing employee wages.

• Understand your numbers.

  • What is your primary threshold and why does it matter?

  • What is my claim cost per point of XMOD?

  • How does my frequency of claims compare to the MEP industry?

  • How does my lost time claim average compare to other MEP contractors?

If you would like assistance understanding how these and other data points impact your company, request a proprietary Key Performance Indicator (KPI) dashboard that puts this information at your fingertips.

You still have time to be proactive, do not let these critical changes catch you by surprise!

2022 Construction Dual Wage Thresholds - An Early Look

Author, Kevin Howard, Account Executive, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.

There are 16 construction workers’ compensation class code pairs in California, each set up as dual wage classifications. The purpose of these “split” class codes allows the Workers’ Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau (WCIRB) and California insurers to better predict future risk and underwrite with more accuracy.

To illustrate the dual wage threshold, consider a seasoned laborer with years of safety training, exposure awareness, and familiarity with jobsite protocol. This employee is going to be less of a safety risk compared to an apprentice who is still learning his or her trade, the safety techniques and all of the skill associated with a trade. As one might imagine, statistics consistently show a much higher probability of an injury occurring with an apprentice versus a seasoned veteran or journeymen. So, having a dual wage threshold allows carriers to generate pricing based on the employees’ experience and likelihood of having an injury.

Exploring how this can directly impact rates and pricing, the 2021 roofing dual wage class codes of 5552 and 5553 is a great example.

Class code 5552 is defined as roofers who make less than $27 per hour. The average California worker’s compensation insurance base rate for this class code is $40 per $100 of payroll. Class code 5553 includes roofers who make $27 or more per hour. This class code’s average California workers’ compensation insurance base rate is $20 per $100 of payroll. In this example, the workers’ compensation premium base rate is half the cost for a more experienced employee over someone with less experience.

It is crucial for any roofing contractor to be mindful of this wage threshold data knowing that the delta in the 2022 recommended increase represents a staggering 61% gap between the two base rates.

Additionally, the WCIRB has continued to increase wage thresholds. This is to keep up with inflation of the US dollar, the increase in minimum wage and the demand for labor, among other factors.

Dual Wage Classification Thresholds by Year

Shown below are the wage thresholds for all dual wage classifications. For information about these classifications, see the California Workers' Compensation Uniform Statistical Reporting Plan—1995, effective September 1, 2021.

Classifications
Year	5027	5140	5183	5185	5201	5403	5446	5467	5474	5484	5538	5552	5632	6218	6307	6315
	5028	5190	5187	5186	5205	5432	5547	5470	5482	5485	5542	5553	5633	6620	6308	6316
9/1/2022	$32	$34	$31	$32	$32	$39	$38	$36	$31	$36	$29	$29	$39	$39	$39	$39
9/1/2021	$28	$32	$28	$29	$28	$35	$36	$33	$28	$32	$27	$27	$35	$34	$34	$34
1/1/2021	$28	$32	$28	$29	$28	$35	$36	$33	$28	$32	$27	$27	$35	$34	$34	$34
1/1/2020	$28	$32	$28	$29	$28	$35	$36	$33	$28	$32	$27	$27	$35	$34	$34	$34
1/1/2019	$27	$32	$26	$27	$25	$32	$34	$32	$26	$29	$27	$25	$32	$31	$31	$31
1/1/2018	$27	$32	$26	$27	$25	$32	$34	$31	$26	$29	$27	$25	$32	$31	$31	$31
1/1/2017	$27	$30	$26	$27	$24	$30	$33	$31	$24	$27	$27	$23	$30	$30	$30	$30

© 2021 Workers' Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau of California. All Rights Reserved.

WCIRB’s 2022 RECOMMENDATION:

The Bureau is considering raising the hourly wage threshold for all 16 dual wage classification pairs with some codes seeing as much as a $5.00 increase. The average delta between the lower advisory rate and higher advisory rate is 48%.

 Proposed Dual Wage Threshold Increases

Dual Wage Classifications	Existing Threshold	Proposed Increase	Proposed Threshold	Low Wage Advisory Rate	High Wage Advisory Rate	% Difference From Low Wage Rate
5027/5028 Masonry	$28	$4	$32	$8.18	$4.21	-48.50%
5190/5140 Electrical Wiring	$32	$2	$34	$3.76	$1.45	-61.40%
5183/5187 Plumbing	$28	$3	$31	$5.31	$2.36	-55.60%
5185/5186 Automatic Sprinkler	$29	$3	$32	$4.57	$1.00	-57.30%
5201/5205 Concrete Work	$28	$4	$32	$6.64	$1.95	-36.30%
5403/5432 Carpentry	$35	$4	$39	$10.03	$4.23	-55.10%
5446/5447 Wallboard Installation	$36	$2	$38	$5.42	$4.50	-55.10%
5467/5470 Glaziers	$33	$3	$36	$7.62	$2.65	-59.30%
5474/5482 Painting Waterproofing	$28	$3	$31	$8.09	$3.10	-46.40%
5484/5485 Plastering or Stucco	$32	$4	$36	$9.98	$4.34	-37.40%
5538/5542 Sheet Metal Work	$27	$2	$29	$5.07	$2.52	-50.30%
5552/5553 Roofing	$27	$2	$29	$21.05	$8.14	-61.30%
5632/5633 Steel Framing	$35	$4	$39	$10.03	$4.50	-55.10%
6218/6220 Grading/Land Leveling	$34	$5	$39	$5.10	$2.93	-42.50%
6307/6308 Sewer Construction	$34	$5	$39	$6.98	$2.84	-59.30%
6315/6316 Water/Gas Mains	$34	$5	$39	$4.18	$3.70	-11.50%

This recommendation, if approved by the insurance commissioner, would become effective September 1, 2022.

With the continuing labor shortage in the construction arena, employers have been doing everything possible to retain employees by offering richer benefits plans, pay increases and merit bonuses, when applicable. These recommended wage classification increases could potentially push employers to extend additional pay raises to employees in an effort to minimize workers’ compensation premiums.

It is best for contractors who utilize any of the 16 dual wage classification pairs to be aware of the potential increases and to do the math to see if it makes sense to consider raises prior to your 2022-2023 September 1st workers’ compensation renewal.

Rancho Mesa predicts that this info will become a major factor in payroll decisions based on overhead cost management and recommend this as a topic for discussion early so that our clients, prospects and listeners can prepare.

To discuss how the proposed dual wage threshold increases may affect your business, contact me at (619) 438-6874 or khoward@ranchomesa.com.