Author, Dave Garcia, President, Rancho Mesa Insurance Services, Inc.
There are many insurance professionals that have tried to quantify the real cost of indemnity or lost time claims, using multipliers anywhere from 2 to 4 times the claim amount in an effort to determine what the real cost of a claim will be to a company. While this may be true, it remains subjective to many. Let me help you understand the ways this type of claim will impact you and then you can decide the real impact to your business.
Let’s assume a claim where the injured worker will be out for 2 to 3 months and the claim’s total incurred amount (which is the combination of paid dollars and reserves) is $50,000. This claim can and will impact your business.
The first direct hit will be your experience modification (X-Mod). While a claim in your current term is delayed a year before going into the calculation, you’ll feel the effects of the remaining 3 years. So, assume the claim is in your 2022-2023 policy year, claims from that year will not go into your 2023-24 policy year but will be in the next three policy terms, 2024-2025, 2025-2026 and 2026-2027.
Each company develops their own “primary threshold,” a term used to describe the maximum incurred loss or cap that any one claim can impact the experience modification. It’s confusing to many policyholders, but this amount regularly changes year-to-year for most companies, as it is derived by the Workers’ Compensation Insurance Rating Bureau (WCIRB) based on the payrolls and class codes a particular business uses and reports.
To simplify this for our clients, we developed a proprietary Key Performance Indicator (KPI) Dashboard that calculates client’s individual Primary Threshold, also detailing how many points to the X-Mod it would add giving them a true indication as to the cost of the claim as it pertains to the X-Mod. Request a personalized KPI for your company.
Now that we understand the impact to the X-Mod, what other areas will be impacted? The next most obvious is the workers compensation carrier’s loss ratio. Adding claim dollars will negatively skew percentages and undoubtedly cause an increase in premium of some amount at renewal.
While the impact to the X-Mod and loss ratio are easy to understand, they are really just the tip of the iceberg. Let’s go below the surface and look at other ways this claim will impact your business.
Losing an employee for any length of time is impactful, but losing the employee for a month or two would likely require the business to fill that person’s job and responsibilities within the company. In many cases this means trying to hire someone new to the organization.
Without going into great detail, the business is likely going to experience additional payroll and benefit costs, training, and likely a decrease in expertise which will most certainly impact the productivity of that particular job.
I think we can all now understand how a lost time claim affects the X-Mod, loss ratio, and a business’s productivity and profitability, both immediately and into the future.
So, what can I do to avoid this or at least minimize the impact should a lost time injury occur? The great news is that in many instances you can prevent these injuries from ever happening or at least reduce the frequency of them occurring. Start with these strategies and enlist your insurance broker for their guidance in the process:
Perform a complete overview of your safety program.
Make changes in training that address your specific needs.
Increase awareness and accountability of those employees responsible for the implementation of your safety program – consider adding this as an area of their annual performance appraisal.
Identify new employees so that your experienced people can mentor them in training or in watching how they are performing. Statistics show that new employees (defined as less than 6 months) have the highest percentage of injuries. New hires in construction can wear different colored hard hats, gloves, vests or even a sticker on their clothing, anything that might let the crew leader know who might need a little more oversight.
Choose the right workers compensation carrier. In general, look for a carrier that offers in-house claims handling, loss control services, can show you statistically both their performance in closing claims vs. the industry, claim costs vs. the industry, medical cost containment performance, length of time doing business in the state you are in. These are just a few items to consider that can result in the best claim outcome should one occur.
Choose the right insurance advisor (broker). Are they a specialist within your industry? What client services do they offer pertaining to trainings you need? Do they offer workshops, webinars and safety certifications? Do they have an experienced workers compensation claim advocate in house to assist you in both understanding your claims and mitigating costs? What tools do they have to help you benchmark yourself against your industry? Can they help you identify trends and root causes?
We’ve seen how one lost time claim can have a negative rippling affect for your company in both your productivity and your profitability. It may feel overwhelming in how to understand and fix your issues with all the other areas of your business that you have to be involved with. It really doesn’t have to be, it’s just time to look at who you choose to work with from your carrier to your broker differently.
Contact us via our website or reach out to me directly at dgarcia@ranchomesa.com.